In the high-frequency region, several bands corresponding to O–H stretching vibrations (ν O–H) are observed. These include a strong band at 3354 cm− 1, medium-intensity bands at 3164 cm− 1 and weaker features at 3398 cm− 1 and 3015 cm− 1. A shoulder peak at 1628 cm⁻¹ is assigned to the H–O–H bending mode (δ H–O–H), likely indicating the presence of adsorbed water.
The fingerprint region contains the complex set of vibrations arising from the borate anion network. The antisymmetric stretching vibrations of trigonally coordinated boron (νₐₛ B(3)–O) are identified as a shoulder at 1410 cm− 1 and medium bands at 1369 cm− 1 and 1327 cm− 1. The symmetric stretching modes of B(3)–O (νₛ B(3)–O) appear as medium-intensity bands at 969 cm⁻¹ and 939 cm⁻¹. Vibrations involving tetrahedrally coordinated boron (B(4)) are also prominent. The antisymmetric stretches (νₐₛ B(4)–O) produce strong bands at 1112 cm− 1 and 1042 cm− 1, a weaker band at 1011 cm− 1, and contribute to weaker features at 1217 cm− 1 and 1195 cm− 1. The latter bands also involve in-plane B–O–H bending modes. Strong bands at 889 cm− 1 and 820 cm− 1 are attributed to symmetric B(4)–O stretches (νₛ B(4)–O) coupled with O–B–O bending deformations.
Thermal behavior
The DSC and TG curves are shown in Fig. 6. Endothermic effect in the region of 100°C is associated with the dehydration of boric acid and the release of residual "mother liquor” contained in the sample. Also, the DSC curve reveals an endothermic effect starting at 525°C, corresponding to the decomposition of Sr[B8O11(OH)4]. The TG curve exhibits two regions where mass losses of 2.0 and 2.5 wt. % occur, associated with dehydration and the subsequent loss of two water molecules (calc. 3.6 wt. % for each water molecule).
Based on the X-ray data obtained, the Sr[B8O11(OH)4] structure is stable at temperatures of 30–390°C (Fig. 7), after which the compound decomposes forming an amorphous phase up to a temperature of 690°C, above which Sr3B14O24 crystallizes.
The evolution of the unit cell parameters of Sr[B8O11(OH)4] upon heating is shown in Fig. 8. The changes in the unit cell parameters a, b, and c are almost linear. Temperature dependences of unit-cell parameters and volume over 30–360°C temperature range can be described by the following equations:
a = 7.6277(31) + 0.000088(14)t
b = 8.13882(93) + 0.0000459(42)t
c = 9.9459(27) + 0.000028(12)t
β = 108.572(33) – 0.00037(15)t
V = 585.29(37) + 0.0130(17)t
The parameters a, b, and c and the unit cell volume increase with temperature, while the β decreases (Fig. 8). At 390°C, the compound begins to decompose, which affects the parameters.
The calculated values of the thermal expansion coefficient are presented in Table 5. The projection of the thermal expansion tensor figure in relation to the crystal structure of Sr[B8O11(OH)4] are shown in Fig. 9. The anisotropy of thermal expansion is determined by the orientation of borate-oxygen layers consisting of vertex-linked hexaborate and diborate groups. These layers are parallel to the bc plane, and within this plane, expansion is minimal (α22 = 6, α33 = 2.5 × 10− 6 °C− 1), while in the direction nearly perpendicular to it, expansion is maximal (α11 = 14 × 10− 6 °C− 1). Additionally, the anisotropy of thermal expansion can be caused by shear deformations in the monoclinic plane, which are sharply anisotropic in nature (Filatov 2008). The decrease of the monoclinic angle (Table 5) is accompanied by the intensive expansion along [101] direction and weak thermal expansion including contraction along [10–1] and nearest directions.
Table 5
Coefficients of the thermal expansion of Sr[B8O11(OH)4], 10–6 °C–1
|
α11
|
α22
|
α33
|
µα1
|
µc3
|
αα
|
αβ
|
αγ
|
αβ
|
αV
|
|
14(2)
|
6(1)
|
2.5(3)
|
27.4
|
8.9
|
12(2)
|
6(1)
|
3(1)
|
-3(1)
|
22(3)
|
A
The temperature-dependent vibrational entropy S was computed in the range from 0 to 1000 K. As shown in Fig.
S1 and Table S2, S increases monotonically with temperature, following the expected trend as more phonon modes become thermally populated. At synthesis should be considered for stability (280 K), the vibrational entropy is calculated to be J/K/mol (per formula unit) of Sr[B
8O
11(OH)
4]. The compound analyzed contained 56 atoms/formula (unit cell), so it has many vibrational modes and complex nature. Temperature of synthesis should be considered for stability (553 K) and it is well above Debye temperature for many modes, so many are thermally excited. For comparison simple solids at 298 K have S ~ 50–150 J/K/mol. At 553 K, plus 56 atoms, ~ 1000–1500 J/K/mol is plausible. Our value is lower because some modes are optical/high-frequency (B-H, O-H stretches > 1000 cm⁻¹). Also, quantum statistics reduce entropy below classical limit, and some modes may be stiffer. The calculated entropy is physically meaningful; it is moderately high (as expected for a complex borate at elevated temperature) but not anomalously high. The enthalpy
H of Sr[B
8O
11(OH)
4] is − 7.35 eV/atom. This value is the most appropriate for total energy comparisons and standard thermodynamic calculations, as it extrapolates the electronic energy to the limit of zero electronic entropy. The influence of vibrational entropy,
TS, or the entropic energy contribution, at 550 K is 11.13 eV/atom, which is a value comparable to enthalpy
H. S may be important when considering stability of Sr[B
8O
11(OH)
4] in comparison with the enthalpy-based convex hull consideration, which requires further study.
High-temperature crystal chemistry of M[B8O11(OH)4] family, M = Ca, Sr, Ba, Sn, Pb, Eu
Within the M[B8O11(OH)4] family, two groups of compounds can be distinguished. The first group includes members with M = Ca, Sr, Eu; these compounds are non-centrosymmetric, space group P21. The second group includes members with M = Sn, Pb, Ba; they are centrosymmetric, space group P2₁/n. All members of this family contain topologically identical borate-oxygen layers (8B:5Δ3T:[φ]<Δ2T>|<Δ2T>|<Δ2T>|2Δ). Furthermore, in addition to the inversion center, the unit cell is doubled in size in the second group. In the structures of members with M = Ca, Sr, Eu, adjacent borate-oxygen layers are related by translation, whereas in the structures of members with M = Sn, Pb, Ba, adjacent layers are related by an n-glide plane and are consequently shifted relative to each other by a ½ translation along the two axes parallel to this B-O layer. The polytypism in this family within the framework of OD theory was previously discussed in (Belokoneva et al., 1999).
The thermal stability of M[B8O11(OH)4] compounds varies with the cation, the decomposition temperature of the compound increases with increasing cation size. Sn[B8O11(OH)4] decomposes in multiple endothermic steps between 150°C and 380°C, ultimately yielding SnO2 and an amorphous boron oxide phase (Schönegger et al. 2018). Sr[B8O11(OH)4] as mentioned above, decomposes above 390°C. Pb[B8O11(OH)4] is stable up to approximately 400°C before dehydrating (Wang et al. 2006). Ba[B8O11(OH)4] undergoes a sharp dehydration step at 543°C, losing two water molecules to form anhydrous BaB8O13 (Sun et al. 2010).
The overall mean volume thermal expansion coefficient for strontium borates is approximately 36 × 10− 6 °C− 1, which is greater than the value obtained for Sr[B8O11(OH)4] (Bubnova and Filatov 2013; Filatov et al. 2016). The nature of thermal expansion is determined by the crystal structure by the geometry and connectivity of their primary building units: in the presence of BO3 triangles, expansion is usually anisotropic and is maximum in the direction perpendicular to the plane of the triangles – the direction of weaker inter-polyhedral bonding – as observed in Sr3B2O6, SrB2O4, Sr2B2O5 (Filatov et al. 2016; Volkov et al. 2017).
Having taken into consideration all M–O bonds no longer than 3.2 Å, one obtains CN(M2+) = 9 for all the related M[B8O11(OH)4]. The effective coordination numbers (ECoNs) are similar for all those compounds except M = Sn (Table S2). A structure-forming role of a particle in the formation of the observed crystal structure is believed to inversely correlate with the dimensionless parameter < G3> (Blatov 2004), a weighted mean of normalized second moments of inertia of VDP calculated for the isolated substructure of chemically identical particles. The more the value of < G3>, the less uniformly the particles occupy space. In most ionic structures, at least one kind of substructure was found to be highly uniform with a small < G3 > value (Shevchenko and Blatov 2024). For both M2+ and the 3-c oxygen (OIII) in the center of FBB, <G3 > ≈ 0.082 in all the six related structures, indicating that the anionic framework and the cations are of approximately equal structure-forming significance. However, a tiny difference does exist for the centrosymmetric and the non-centrosymmetric structures, as it can be seen from Table S2: for the centrosymmetric structures the arrangement of M2+ is slightly less uniform than that of OIII. A single cluster representation was found for Nζ = 6: clusters [B8O9(OH)4O4/2] form 4-c plane net with a simple topological type sql (square lattice) (Fig. 10). Hydrogen bonds between clusters connect these plane nets into 8-coordinated framework of topological type bcu (body-centered cubic lattice), the second most frequent type for 3-periodic coordination polymers in cluster representation (Alexandrov et al. 2011). Types pcu and bcu are also top 2 in terms of Shannon complexity (Krivovichev 2024).
Despite different space groups, the topologies of all members of M[B8O11(OH)4], M = Ca, Sr, Ba, Sn, Pb, Eu are the same. Cluster [B8O9(OH)4O4/2] is achiral, as its highest possible point group CS contains improper rotation and is incompatible with chirality. Thus, there seems to be no firm reason for Sr[B8O11(OH)4] to crystallize in a Sohncke space group aside from probably some energetic benefit from conformational adjustment of clusters. Space groups P21 and P21/n each have 3 generating operations in a minimal generating subset (Banaru et al. 2025). Consequently, for the formation of 3-periodic framework of clusters occupying a sole general position of the space group (which is the case in both the structures), 3 sorts of edges would be enough (Banaru et al. 2025). Meanwhile, the realization of net bcu in both the structures contains a redundant sort of edges: upon removing any of two sorts of edges accounting for H-bonds, the net would acquire another type, pcu (primitive cubic lattice), the first most frequent type for 3-periodic coordination polymers in cluster representation (Alexandrov et al. 2011). Types pcu and bcu are also top 2 in terms of Shannon complexity (Krivovichev 2024).
Given the nonlinear optical properties of the members with M = Ca and Sr, it is interesting to understand the reasons for the formation of non-centrosymmetric phases in the M[B8O11(OH)4] family. The dependence of the unit cell volume on the M2+ ionic radius (for C.N. 8 (Shannon 1976; Sidey 2022)) is shown in Fig. 11. The unit cell volume of the non-centrosymmetric compounds is larger than that of the centrosymmetric ones. It can be seen that the non-centrosymmetric structures occur for divalent metals with an ionic radius of ~ 1.00–1.25 Å and without a stereochemically active lone pair (which is present for Sn2+ and Pb2+). Considering that for M = Ca, the nonlinear optical response is stronger than for Sr (Gong et al., 2020), the established correlation can be used for further searches for nonlinear optical materials within the M[B8O11(OH)4] family.