A
Spectrum of CT findings of acquired adult non-neuromyopathic ocular dysmotility inflicted by traumatic and non-traumatic afflictions of extra-ocular muscles.
Article title
Abstract
Background
Acquired adult ocular dysmotility are relatively common caused by variety of traumatic and non-traumatic disorders affecting the extra-ocular muscles (EOMs). Computed tomography (CT) is a quick and widely available imaging modality that provides a key role in evaluating these conditions by delineating muscle morphology and excellent bone and soft-tissue visualization.
Aim of the study: to characterize and categorize the spectrum of CT findings in some acquired adult non-neuromyopathic ocular dysmotility caused by both traumatic and non-traumatic extra-ocular muscle afflictions, providing a practical imaging framework for radiologists and referring clinicians.
Methods
A
40 adult patients were included in this retrospective study (with a mean age of ~ 30 years (range 16–50).; 70% male) presenting with acquired traumatic and non-traumatic ocular dysmotility with exclusion of congenital, neuromyopathic, or neurogenic causes. All underwent non-contrast orbital CT. Demographic data, clinical features, affected muscles, laterality, and CT findings—including fracture lines, muscle morphology, and associated orbital or sinus abnormalities—were analyzed.
Results
Traumatic etiologies slightly predominated (52.5%) over non-traumatic causes (47.5%) with blunt orbital trauma was the most common cause (52.5%). While myopia-related disorders (22.5%) and isolated idiopathic cases (20%) comprised the majority of non-traumatic etiologies.
The inferior rectus and superior oblique muscles were the most frequently affected EOMs (27.5% each), followed by the medial rectus (22.5%). CT findings demonstrated thinning or atrophy (50%), with detachment/disinsertion in (22.5%)
Orbital wall fractures were identified in 22.5% and sinusitis in 27.5% of cases with optic nerve was intact in all patients. In non-traumatic cases, thyroid ophthalmopathy manifested as muscle hypertrophy, while high-myopia–related strabismus fixus manifested as muscle elongation and displacement.
Conclusion
CT provides a non-invasive, available, rapid, and comprehensive tool for evaluating both traumatic and non-traumatic causes of acquired ocular dysmotility in adults. It effectively characterizes the pattern and extent of ocular dysmotility, guiding diagnosis, and surgical planning and follow up.
Keywords
Ocular dysmotility
Extra-ocular muscles
Computed tomography
Orbital trauma
Myopic strabismus fixus
Thyroid ophthalmopathy
Diplopia.
A
A
Background:
The orbit includes the globe and the retrobulbar space, the retrobulbar space contains six extraocular muscles (EOMs): superior, inferior, medial, and lateral recti, as well as the superior and inferior oblique muscles. These muscles work in coordination to control movements of the eyeball and eyelids. These muscles are an important reference point for strabismus surgery. (1) Intraorbital structures -including the EOMs- can be affected by variety of acquired local and systemic diseases including neurological, metabolic, infiltrative, endocrine such as Graves’ disease and traumatic causes. (2)
A
Ocular motility disorders are relatively common and may be a significant source of discomfort and morbidity. Although the presence of restricted eye movement can be detected clinically, determining the underlying cause of ocular dysmotility often requires imaging evaluation. Imaging plays a crucial role in excluding and detecting a specific cause responsible for the clinical presentation. However, the radiologist should be aware that the imaging findings in many of these conditions when taken in isolation from the clinical history and symptoms are often nonspecific. (3) In such cases, it is necessary to evaluate the changes in orbital structures carefully to investigate the severity of the disease, to plan the treatment correctly, to predict the postoperative outcome, and also to evaluate the response to the treatment. (4)
Thyroid disease is a multifactorial disease affecting orbital structures such as adipose tissue and extraocular muscle with inflammatory changes that can cause disfiguring and sight-threatening injuries. (5) Patients may experience as exophthalmos, eyelid retraction, lateral flare, strabismus, and optic neuropathy. (6)
Although the diagnosis of Graves ophthalmopathy (GO) is based on clinical findings, imaging exams, including magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), computed tomography (CT), and ultrasonography can add valuable information on tissue microstructure, leading to new findings on actual disease progress and status, which is vital for planning treatment and interventions. (7)
Imaging in patients with GO may reveal an increase in orbital fibroadipose tissue, enlargement of extraocular muscles, and optic-nerve compression. Imaging is especially warranted in cases of asymmetric proptosis and for differential diagnosis. (8)
Extraocular muscle enlargement is the most common sign among these patients, usually affecting younger and older patients differently. The inferior rectus muscle is the most frequently involved in clinical myopathy, followed by medial, superior, and lateral rectus muscles, respectively. In GO, multiple muscles can be involved simultaneously and/or bilaterally in 76% to 90% of the cases. (9)
According to Su et al., younger patients are less affected by motility restriction despite developing more proptosis even with enlarged muscles, whereas older patients suffer from more motility restriction and diplopia due to the muscle bellies enlargement posterior in the orbit. Proptosis is mainly related to the most enlarged muscle position than the size itself. (10)
Diagnosis is based on patient’s history, clinical manifestations, and typical features on computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging. The appearance of the tendonous muscle insertion on the globe seen with neuroimaging may help distinguish idiopathic orbital inflammatory syndrome (IOIS) from the muscle enlargement of orbital Grave's disease: thickened, involved tendons with IOIS; thin, normal-appearing tendons with orbital Graves disease (although they do sometimes enhance). (11)
Orbital fractures are typically the result of middle third facial traumas. Blow out fractures are usually associated with injuries to surrounding soft tissues and orbital cavity contents. They may cause entrapment or herniation of orbital fat and extraocular muscles, resulting in limited eye movements and/or enophthalmos due to intra-orbital volume reduction. The inferior orbital wall is the most commonly involved site, followed by the medial orbital wall. (12)
CT represents the gold standard for investigating suspected orbital fractures and identifying foreign bodies, due to the excellent bone and soft-tissue visualization. CT is a quick and widely available imaging modality. Thanks to the possibility of multiplanar and tridimensional reconstructions, CT is also the primary imaging modality for surgical planning of fracture reconstructions and treatment management. (12)
Direct EOM involvement can range from mild: minimal displacement from adjacent soft tissue edema or hemorrhage; to moderate: contusion of the EOM itself; to severe: disinsertion, laceration, or incarceration of the EOM from the traumatic blow or by an orbital fracture. Indirectly, EOM motility may be impaired from cranial nerve palsy or supranuclear injury associated with head and neck trauma. The goal of EOM management during acute ocular or orbital surgery is to limit the amount of fibrosis that could occur and result in strabismus. (13)
EOM entrapment or flap tears may follow orbital fractures, which comprise the most common cause of traumatic strabismus. The resultant strabismus depends on the fracture location and extent of EOM involvement. (13)
Bony fragments can impinge surrounding EOMs, commonly the inferior rectus, inferior oblique, and medial rectus, and less commonly, the superior oblique. (14)
The aim of this study to characterize and categorize the spectrum of CT findings in some acquired adult non-neuromyopathic ocular dysmotility caused by both traumatic and non-traumatic extra-ocular muscle afflictions, providing a practical imaging framework for radiologists and referring clinicians. We meant to include the uncommon traumatic, degenerative, metabolic and idiopathic causes which are uncommonly discussed in radiology literature and uncommonly afflict the EOMs to cause strabismus. We meant to exclude the more common neuro-muscular disorders discussed on MRI basis.
Methods
Study Design and Patient Selection:
A
Retrospective study included 40 adult patients who underwent orbital CT imaging at our main tertiary university hospital between February 2022 and February 2024, while Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval was obtained, and informed consent was waived due to the retrospective nature of the research.
Inclusion criteria:
included adult patients (> 16 years) with clinical diagnosis of limitation of ocular movement due to extra-ocular muscle (EOM) pathology which detected on CT.
Exclusion criteria:
Patients with congenital, neuromyopathic, or neurogenic causes of ocular dysmotility were excluded.
Based on clinical and imaging data, patients were categorized into two main groups: traumatic and non-traumatic causes.
A
CT Imaging Protocol:
All patients underwent non contrast multidetector CT scan of the orbits using a [……]. Scans were obtained in both axial and coronal planes, with thin-section (0.5–1 mm) reconstructions.
Imaging parameters included:
Tube voltage: 120 kVp, Tube current: 150–250 mAs (automatically adjusted), Matrix size: 512 × 512, Field of view: tailored to the orbit
Multiplanar reconstruction and 3D reformat were used for better evaluation of extra ocular muscles involvement and adjacent orbital structures and paranasal sinuses.
Images Evaluation
Two very well experienced subspecialized radiologists (each with > 10 years’ experience) independently reviewed the generated images, blinded to clinical diagnosis.
Image interpretation:
Each case was assessed according the following parameters: side and laterality, which muscle (s) was affected either single muscle or combination, morphological changes including (thinning, atrophy, hypertrophy, disinsertion, displacement, or tear). Type and site of tear were also assessed. Other associated CT findings such as orbital fractures, orbital fat herniation, preseptal edema, sinus disease, or prior surgical repair were reported.
Statistical Analysis
The statistical analyses were performed by specialized personnel, using SPSS v26 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY). Descriptive statistics were used to summarize demographic and imaging findings. Quantitative variables were expressed as mean ± standard deviation, and categorical variables as frequencies and percentages. Interobserver agreement was assessed using Cohen’s kappa coefficient.
Results
A
This study included 40 patients and consisted predominantly of males (70%), with a mean age of ~ 30 years (range 16–50). Table 1
A
According to presentation, Left-sided strabismus and myopic strabismus fixus accounted for more than half of presentations (30% and 22.5%, respectively) (Fig. 1). Most patients had a slow onset of diplopia (70%) and long-standing disease (70%). By etiology, blunt orbital trauma was the most common cause (52.5%) (Fig. 2). While myopia-related disorders (22.5%) (Fig. 4) and isolated idiopathic cases (20%) (Fig. 1) comprised the majority of non-traumatic etiologies. Only two patients (5%) had thyroid ophthalmopathy (Fig. 5), and hyperthyroidism was the only recorded systemic comorbidity. Table 2
A
Fig. 1
Sequential cases of strabismus created by EOM atrophy by degenerative or idiopathic factors: Case 1 in (a, b): A 29 years old male) showing atrophy of medial rectus (red arrow) in (a) and of superior oblique muscle pointed by orange arrow in (b), both showed diffuse diminution of girths along their lengths. This is created by old eye surgery with prolonged pressure and traction during surgery. Case-2 in (c, d) is a 34 years old female with isolated atrophy of IRs muscles bilaterally pointed by orange arrows in (c) with no clear cause (idiopathic) and sagittal CT image in (d) shows atrophic IR of its muscle bulk as pointed by yellow short arrow; the red arrow points to rolled up eye by effect of SR creating superior strabismus. The third case of adult male patient shows isolated idiopathic atrophy of right LR pointed by red arrow in coronal CT mage in (e) and (f) showing marked loss if muscle girth and fatty replacement with no relevant causative factor (Idiopathic isolated LR atrophy).
A
Fig. 2
A 32 years old male patient shows post traumatic fracture blow out of inferior rectus (orange arrow in (a) and (b)with evidence of fat entrapment and complete full thickness flap tear of the inferior rectus muscle in sagittal CT image pointed by red arrow in (b). another patient in (c,d,e,f) showing simple blow out of medial wall (arrow in c), associated with entrapped MR (arrow in d) showing change in direction in medial wall, with "rounded sign" with slightly thickened girth, axial CT in (e) shows medial bowing of lamina papyracea, and additional complex type of blow-out fracture of inferior wall (f) showing comminution and blow out with entrapped IR revealing thickened substance and inferior displacement towards the site of blow out.
A
Fig. 4
A 30 years old female patient with clinical ophthalmological diagnosis of "Myopic strabismic fixus", suffering long term high myopia, showing marked buphthalmias of eye globes on coronal CT image; AP measures 30 and 27 mm for right and left eyes respectively, Yellow Arrow: Nasal Displacement of SR Green Arrow: thinned out LR in (a) with clear close opposition of enlarged eye globes against the bony orbital walls, while Red arrow in (b): Thinned stretched infero-laterally dispaled LR, opposed to lateral wall. Coronal CT in (c) shows bilateral nasal displacement of thickened SR, more on right side due to severe degree of disease and larger more elongated eye globe. Axial CT images (d) and (e) from another patient with same diagnosis of "heavy eye syndrome" who is a 34 years old male patient () showing increased AP length of globes, seen opposed to lateral orbital wall in (d) while Axial CT in (e) shows secondary morphological changes of EOMs: Nsal Displacement of slightly thinner SRs Red Arrows point to streatched thinned out LRs with inferor-latreal dispalcement nearly stuck to latreal walls.
A
Fig. 5
A case of post traumatic strabismus in an adult 23 years old female presenting with exotropia of left eye. A subtle blow out is seen (green arrow) in (a) seen as subtle excavation of lamina papyracea, and is opposed by bulky retracted portion of MR, with absence of anterior portion (yellow arrow) due to retraction, red arrows point to right normal MR and SOV superior ophthalmic vein on left side. Intact SO is seen on both sides with intact trochlea in (b)and (c)at different levels. Another patient with left sided strabismus (inferior exoptropia) due to SO dysfunction proven by trochlear calcification as seen in axial CT image, arrow in (d) and in coronal CT image, red arrow in (e). A third case of thyroid orbitopathy showed hypertrophy and fatty replacement of IR outlined by arrow in (f) in sagittal CT image of a 56 years old male patient with vertical diplopia and known chronic uncontrolled thyroid dysfunction disease. Coronal CT image for comparison of two sides (g).
Table (1): Patients characteristic (n = 40)
A
In more than half of patients (52.5%), muscle involvement was left-sided while bilateral in 20%. The inferior rectus and superior oblique muscles were the most frequently affected EOMs (27.5% each), followed by the medial rectus (22.5%) (Figs. 13). CT findings demonstrated thinning or atrophy (50%), with detachment/disinsertion in (22.5%) and full-thickness tears in (7.5%). Nearly 40% of patients had no additional orbital abnormalities; when present, blow-out floor fractures (15%) predominated. (Fig. 2) Table 3
A
Fig. 3
A 12 years old male child, suffering pos traumatic strabismus, related to previous trauma to the eye: (a) shows near total dis-insertion and detachment of the right medial rectus muscle from its scleral insertion with slightly bulky flesh muscle due to tendon retraction; site of detachment pointed by red arrow in (a) and (b) with latter showing comparison with normal contra-lateral counterpart muscle also by sagittal CT image and more comparison of muscle bellies in coronal CT image in (c). Another pediatric 5 years old patient in (d), (e) and (f) suffering post traumatic strabismus: Axial CT image in (d) shows SO disinsertion: Orange Arrow: Normal Trochlea of SO mucle on right side, Red Arrow: Hazy ill defined thinned left SO Trochlea on left side due to traumatic disinsertion, Yelow Arrowhead: Taumatic prenasal edema crossing both sides with bilateral pre-septal edema (d). coronal CT images in (e)and (f) show comparison of girths of traumatized and normal SO muscles.
A
No fracture was found in 77.5% of cases. when present, inferior or medial wall blow-out fractures was found to be accounted for 7.5% for each (Fig. 2). According to muscle tears, extra-ocular muscle tear was confirmed by CT in nine patients (22.5%), two-thirds of which were full-thickness (Figs. 2 and 3). The optic nerve was intact in all cases. Adjacent sinusitis was present in 27.5% of cases. Table 4
Discussion:
In the present study, majority were young males (mean age ~ 30 years, 70% male), and the trauma was slightly more common (52.5%) than non-traumatic causes (47.5%), with blunt orbital trauma dominating the traumatic category, reflecting the higher risk of trauma in this group.
Parallel to our results, Li et al. [15] found that eye injuries disproportionately affect young/ middle ages males, with largely unintentional mechanisms (sports/occupational/transport). Also, Bineshfar et al. [16] included 49,765 cases; 79% male; mean age 27 ± 19 y. Sports implicated in such injuries included baseball, bicycling, and softball, all consistent with high-energy orbital impacts that can entrap or injure extraocular muscles (EOMs). Furthermore, Wee et al. [17] in a Korean series found that cases with muscle entrapment skewed younger (median 17 y) compared with all blow-outs (mean 34 y), reinforcing that EOM-related dysmotility after trauma clusters in younger patients. Another study by Chen et al. [18] found that among 36 patients with traumatic or iatrogenic EOM ruptures, two-thirds were male and the mean age was 34 y. In an Egyptian cases series, Soliman and Macky [19] reported marked male predominance among ocular trauma admissions.
Our study included 6 cases of blow out floor and 3 of blow out medial wall, which is matching with agreed on by literature that weakest orbital wall is floor followed by medial wall, both can yield under pressure created by blow out. A case had combined walls comminuted blow out. Patients with post-blow out strabismus are those suffering significant EOM entrapment into fracture site, and only included in our study.
Parallel to these results, Lee et al. [20] found that in patients with orbital wall fractures, up to 100% had ocular motility disturbance, and 89–98% experienced diplopia, indicating that blunt orbital trauma is a potent cause of EOM dysfunction. Also, Goelz et al. [21] found that orbital injuries were confirmed in 23.6% of patients with facial injuries, and soft tissue involvement—including muscle displacement—was frequent (e.g., 44.6% showed EOM displacement). This underlines the prominent role of trauma in EOM-related pathologies. The entrapped muscle looks deviated and pulled into site of fracture with thickening and hypertrophy of its flesh created by traction.
Strabismus associated with high myopia was the leading non-traumatic cause. This is coined specific terms as myopia-associated strabismus (“heavy eye syndrome”). Disease is usually bilateral and in middle age (Female > Male), and still can occur unilaterally and in older or younger ages. Our study included 9 cases of myopic strabismic fixus: 6 females: 3 males, 6 bilateral.
In agreement with our data, Su et al. [22] found that myopia-associated strabismus (“heavy eye syndrome”) is a rare but significant non-traumatic cause of ocular motility disturbance, resulting from high myopia-associated globe elongation causing muscle displacement and motility restriction. Quite similar, a large European hospital study by Kooger et al. [23] found that non-traumatic ophthalmic conditions (e.g., endocrine or myopic changes) often accounted for a substantial number of ocular motility consultations.
Similar to our results, a Level I trauma center series by Chiang et al.[24] found left orbital fractures significantly more common than right, reinforcing a left-sided trend. Kooger et al.[23] likewise reported left-sided fractures in 50.5% vs 44% right and documented bilateral cases (5.5%), underscoring that while laterality skews left, bilateral involvement does occur. Complementing these epidemiologic signals, an imaging-mechanistic review by Cellina et al.[12] showed that blow-out fractures frequently involve the orbital floor with lateral or medial wall extension, a pattern that helps explain how typical impact vectors and bony weak points can yield apparent lateral preferences on CT.
Regarding incidence of EOMs involvement in the uncommon etiopathologies resulting in ocular dysmotility: the inferior rectus, superior oblique, and medial rectus were the most commonly affected muscles, with thinning/atrophy being the dominant morphological pattern (50%). The inferior rectus showed highest prevalence of affection (n = 11) being entrapped into a complex blow out, assuming a hypertrophied morphology and deviated direction towards fracture site and 3 cases had complete full thickness flap tear. Lateral rectus showed bilateral involvement in heavy eye syndrome (n = 6) appearing thinned stretched along with nasal displacement of superior rectus (SRs). Medial rectus showed high prevalence too (n = 9), being entrapped in medial wall blow out in 3 cases, remaining involved in traumatic disinsertion and post traumatic atrophy. Superior oblique muscle was involved in isolated atrophy in (n = 11) (assumed to be following remote eye surgery due to prolonged displacement and compression) by traction techniques, and sometimes no cause identified, while degenerative calcifications of trochlea was also seen in 2 cases, correlated with limited movement and strabismus not a mere incidental senile finding. The inferior rectus also showed predominant involvement in thyroid-associated orbitopathy being most commonly affected muscle.
Anatomical background can explain variable incidence and involvement of EOMs in pathologies. The inferior rectus lies adjacent to the orbital floor and is prone to entrapment or compression in blow-out fractures; the medial rectus is similarly vulnerable in medial wall injuries; while the superior oblique’s involvement may reflect its role in torsional movement and its susceptibility when orbital support structures are disrupted. The high incidence of thinning or atrophy suggests chronic muscle compromise resulting in volume loss rather than acute swelling, with example exist following prolonged eye surgeries, where medially located EOMs, are tracked for long time resulting in vascular compromise and postulated delayed atrophy [13].
A
In harmony with these data, Tomasetti et al. [25] document an isolated inferior rectus rupture after blunt trauma and noted that the inferior and medial recti muscles are most often involved because of their exposed course and limited protective buttressing. Cellina et al. [12] further show on computerized tomography (CT) that orbital floor fractures commonly displace or herniate the inferior rectus into the maxillary sinus, underscoring its high susceptibility in trauma. Extending this pattern beyond trauma, Fidor-Mikita and Krupski [26] demonstrate that in dysthyroid ophthalmopathy the inferior (61%) and medial rectus (54%) are the most frequently enlarged on CT, indicating that similar anatomical and functional predispositions also drive involvement in non-traumatic disease. In contrast, Chen et al. [18] reviewing isolated EOM ruptures, found superior oblique involvement to be rare (1 patient).
In the current study, multi-slice CT (MSCT) effectively demonstrated fracture lines (22.5% of cases), muscle tears (22.5%), and fat entrapment (15%), highlighting its role in evaluating post-traumatic orbital pathology. CT effectively reveals bony disruptions, delineates soft-tissue involvement such as extra-ocular muscle tears or displacement, and detects orbital fat herniation or entrapment into adjacent sinuses. [27].
In accordance, Cellina et al. [12] showed that CT consistently demonstrates orbital wall fractures with associated soft-tissue herniation (muscle or fat) and can depict globe/nerve injury when present, establishing CT as the first-line map of injury patterns in traumatic emergencies. Also, Folkestad et al. [28] found that the rounding sign of the inferior rectus on CT correlated with soft-tissue herniation and diplopia, underscoring CT’s value for identifying muscle involvement and fat prolapse and for surgical planning. Similarly, Chiang et al. [29] linked CT-detected entrapment (13%) with clinical diplopia (13%) and motility restriction (17%), highlighting CT’s sensitivity for clinically meaningful muscle compromise. In contrast, Lin et al. [30] reported that while CT exceeds 70% sensitivity for entrapment, it is less sensitive for muscle lacerations or intramuscular injuries, implying potential under-detection on CT alone; and Migliorini et al. [31] showed that ocular motility testing may reveal entrapment even when CT appears negative, arguing for integrated imaging–clinical algorithms and selective surgical exploration.
In the present study, hypertrophy/enlargement was the key finding in thyroid ophthalmopathy, while myopic strabismus fixus cases showed elongated or displaced muscles with globe enlargement: These patients had bulky elongated eye globes changing their directions to be in clos opposition to walls, with consequent dynamic changes of the EOMs in response to this directional change of eye globe, mainly infero-laterally. The lateral rectus appears thinned and stretched in shape and directed inferolateral stuck in between lateral wall and globe. The superior rectus tend to show nasal/medial displacement and appears thickened as compensatory response.
In non-traumatic cases, thyroid ophthalmopathy manifested predominantly as extraocular muscle hypertrophy/enlargement, reflecting autoimmune-mediated inflammation and fibrotic remodeling [32]. Contrastingly, myopic strabismus fixus cases displayed distinctive muscle displacement patterns—typically inferior displacement of the lateral rectus and nasal shift of the superior rectus—accompanied by globe elongation and proptosis [22].
In accordance, Fidor-Mikita and Krupski [26] showed the hallmark fusiform, tendon-sparing enlargement of extraocular muscles—predominantly the inferior and medial rectus—with accompanying orbital fat expansion, proptosis, and apex crowding. Also, Xiong et al. [33] used 3D-based CT volumetry to confirm significant increases in both EOM and orbital fat volumes in Thyroid-Associated Orbitopathy (TAO). In addition, Kaur et al. [34] detailed classic myopic strabismus fixus CT signs—nasalized superior rectus and inferiorly displaced lateral rectus in elongated globes. Contrastingly, Enzmann et al. [35] CT work in Graves’ ophthalmopathy corroborates muscle enlargement but lacks today’s resolution and does not delineate modern displacement mechanics; and an MRI-based Case Reports by Gatt et al. [36] descriped heavy-eye syndrome emphasizing LR–SR band thinning and superotemporal globe displacement.
Limitations
This study has several limitations. First, the retrospective nature, relatively small sample size and single center design of the study that may introduce selection bias and may limit generalizability. second, only non-contrast CT was used. Contrast-enhanced CT or MRI could be superior in assessment of muscle inflammation, fibrosis, or vascular compromise. Third, the absence of quantitative metrics, objective measurements such as extra-ocular muscle volumes was not included, and inter-observer variability was not assessed. Finally, Limited clinical correlation, functional and surgical outcomes were not systematically correlated with imaging findings, which could be explored in future prospective multicenter studies combining multimodal imaging (CT and MRI) with clinical correlation and follow-up.
Conclusion
This study highlights the CT spectrum of acquired non-neuromyopathic ocular dysmotility in adults resulting from traumatic and non-traumatic extra-ocular muscle (EOM) etiologies. Trauma— predominantly blunt orbital injury—was slightly more frequent than non-traumatic causes, particularly in young males, highlighting the demographic vulnerability of this group with inferior and medial rectus muscles were the most commonly affected, reflecting their anatomic exposure along the orbital floor and medial wall.
CT was highly effective in detecting the main morphological changes, such as fracture lies, associated fat entrapment and sinus disease as well as muscle tear, entrapment, disinsertion, thinning or atrophy. In non-traumatic etiologies, CT identified characteristic hypertrophy in thyroid ophthalmopathy and elongation or displacement in high-myopia–related strabismus fixus.
Preserved optic nerves across all cases of this study emphasize that dysmotility in this cohort was primarily arising from extraocular muscles rather than neurogenic or optic nerve injury.
Overall, CT provides a non-invasive, available, rapid, and comprehensive tool for evaluating causes and extent of ocular dysmotility, guiding diagnosis, and surgical planning and follow up.
List Of Abbreviations:
EOMs
extraocular muscles
GO
Graves ophthalmopathy
MRI
magnetic resonance imaging
CT
computed tomography
IOIS
idiopathic orbital inflammatory syndrome
SRs
superior rectus
MSCT
multi-slice CT
TAO
Thyroid-Associated Orbitopathy
Declarations
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate:
All procedures followed were in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible committee on human experimentation (Institutional Review Board (IRB)” of Alexandria General Hospital on 14th February 2024) and with the Helsinki Declaration of 1964 and later versions. Committee’s reference number is unavailable (NOT applicable).
Consent for publication:
Not needed in setting of retrospective studies according to our institutional preferences and legislations of ethics committee.
A
Funding:
This study had no funding from any resource.
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate:
All procedures followed were in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible committee on human experimentation (Institutional Review Board (IRB)” of Alexandria General Hospital on 3-8-2025) and with the Helsinki Declaration of 1964 and later versions. Committee’s reference number is IRB NO: 00012098). No consent was obtained from the patients since it was a retrospective study.
Consent for publication:
No consent was obtained from the patients since it was a retrospective study.
A
Data Availability
The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Competing interests:
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
A
Author Contribution
Authors’ contributions: ME provided the cases and final diagnoses, LE gave the idea, provided master table and statistics with detailed description of results, made figure legends, and made the whole final supervision on conducted research. AM wrote the section of introduction
A
Acknowledgement
Not applicable
References
1.
Kiliç Şafak N, Tepecik S. Evaluation of the Normal Measurements of Orbital Structures in Healthy Adult Individuals by Using a Magnetic Resonance Imaging Method. Tomography. 2024;10(11):1706–15.
2.
Al Jabri S, Kirkham J, Rowe FJ. Development of a core outcome set for amblyopia, strabismus and ocular motility disorders: A review to identify outcome measures. BMC ophthalmology. 2019;19(1):47.
3.
Thatcher J, Chang YM, Chapman MN, Hovis K, Fujita A, Sobel R, Sakai O. Clinical-radiologic correlation of extraocular eye movement disorders: seeing beneath the surface. Radiographics. 2016;36(7):2123–39.
4.
Siakallis LC, Uddin JM, Miszkiel KA. Imaging investigation of thyroid eye disease. Ophthalmic Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery. 2018;34(4S):S41-51.
5.
Łacheta D, Miśkiewicz P, Głuszko A, Nowicka G, Struga M, Kantor I, et al. Immunological aspects of graves’ Ophthalmopathy. BioMed Res Int (2019) 12:2019. doi: 10.1155/2019/7453260
6.
Genere N, Stan MN. Current and emerging treatment strategies for graves’ Orbitopathy. Drugs (2019) 79(2):109–24. doi: 10.1007/s40265-018-1045-9
7.
Edmunds MR, Boelaert K. Knowledge of thyroid eye disease in graves’ Disease patients with and without orbitopathy. Thyroid (2019) 29(4):557–62. doi: 10.1089/thy.2018.0665
8.
Wémeau JL, Klein M, Sadoul J, Briet C, Vélayoudom-Céphise F. Graves’ disease: Introduction, epidemiology, endogenous and environmental pathogenic factors. Ann Endocrinol (Paris) (2018) 79(6):599–607. doi: 10.1016/j.ando.2018.09.002
9.
Luccas R, Riguetto CM, Alves M, Zantut-Wittmann DE, Reis F. Computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging approaches to Graves’ ophthalmopathy: a narrative review. Frontiers in Endocrinology. 2024;14:1277961.
10.
Su Y, Liu X, Fang S, Huang Y, Li Y, Zhong S, et al. Age-related difference in extraocular muscles and its relation to clinical manifestations in an ethnically homogenous group of patients with Graves’ orbitopathy. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol (2022) 260(2):583–9. doi: 10.1007/s00417-021-05377-9
11.
Kang MS, Yang HK, Kim N, Hwang JM. Clinical features of ocular motility in idiopathic orbital myositis. Journal of Clinical Medicine. 2020;9(4):1165.
12.
Cellina M, Cè M, Marziali S, Irmici G, Gibelli D, Oliva G, Carrafiello G. Computed tomography in traumatic orbital emergencies: a pictorial essay—imaging findings, tips, and report flowchart. Insights into imaging. 2022;13(1):4.
13.
Tooley AA, Levine B, Godfrey KJ, Lisman RD, Tran AQ, Sherman JE. Inferior Oblique Entrapment After Orbital Fracture With Transection and Repair. Craniomaxillofac Trauma Reconstr. 2020;13(3):211–214
14.
Gómez Roselló E, Quiles Granado AM, Artajona Garcia M, Juanpere Martí S, Laguillo Sala G, Beltrán Mármol B, Pedraza Gutiérrez S. Facial fractures: classification and highlights for a useful report. Insights Imaging. 2020;11(1):49.
15.
Li C, Fu Y, Liu S, Yu H, Yang X, Zhang M, et al. The global incidence and disability of eye injury: an analysis from the Global Burden of Disease Study 2019. EClinicalMedicine. 2023;62.
16.
Bineshfar N, Shields C, Davila N, McLaughlin SA, Pradeep T, Lee WW. The Epidemiology of Sports-Related Orbital Fractures in the United States. Ophthalmology. 2025.
17.
Wee JH, Kim DG, Lee JY, Cho MJ, Shim WS, Jung HJ. A case series of surgical outcomes for orbital blowout fracture with extraocular muscle entrapment. Medicine (Baltimore). 2023;102:e34879.
18.
Chen J, Kang Y, Deng D, Shen T, Yan J. Isolated total rupture of extraocular muscles. Medicine. 2015;94:e1351.
19.
Soliman MM, Macky TA. Pattern of ocular trauma in Egypt. Graefe's archive for clinical and experimental ophthalmology. 2008;246:205–12.
20.
Lee SH, Lew H, Yun YS. Ocular motility disturbances in orbital wall fracture patients. Yonsei Med J. 2005;46:359–67.
21.
Goelz L, Syperek A, Heske S, Mutze S, Hosten N, Kirsch M. Retrospective cohort study of frequency and patterns of orbital injuries on whole-body CT with maxillofacial multi-slice CT. Tomography. 2021;7:373–86.
22.
Su Y, Shen Q, Fan X. Loop Myopexy Surgery for Strabismus Associated with High Myopia. J Ophthalmol. 2016;2016:8657036.
23.
Kooger TJ, Joosse MV, van Minderhout EM, Hergaarden K, Khouw Y-L. Epidemiology of orbital fractures in a large hospital in the Netherlands: results of implementation of a multidisciplinary orbital trauma team. The Open Ophthalmology Journal. 2021;15.
24.
Chiang E, Saadat LV, Spitz JA, Bryar PJ, Chambers CB. Etiology of orbital fractures at a level I trauma center in a large metropolitan city. Taiwan J Ophthalmol. 2016;6:26–31.
25.
Tomasetti P, Metzler P, Jacobsen C. Isolated inferior rectus muscle rupture after blunt orbital trauma. J Surg Case Rep. 2013;2013.
26.
Fidor-Mikita E, Krupski W. Computed tomography imaging of orbits in thyroid orbitopathy. Journal of Pre-Clinical and Clinical Research. 2008;2.
27.
Lee HJ, Jilani M, Frohman L, Baker S. CT of orbital trauma. Emerg Radiol. 2004;10:168–72.
28.
Folkestad L, Jönsson L, Karlsson T. Orbital floor fractures—a comparison between CT images and findings at surgery. European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology. 2023;280:2795–803.
29.
Chiang E, Saadat LV, Spitz JA, Bryar P, French D, Chambers CB. Correlation of Radiographic Muscle Entrapment with Diplopia and Restriction of Extraocular Movements in Patients with Orbital Fractures. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science. 2014;55:5476-.
30.
Lin KY, Ngai P, Echegoyen JC, Tao JP. Imaging in orbital trauma. Saudi J Ophthalmol. 2012;26:427–32.
31.
Migliorini R, Comberiati AM, Pacella F, Longo AR, Messineo D, Trovato Battagliola E, et al. Utility of ocular motility tests in orbital floor fractures with muscle entrapment that is not detected on computed tomography. Clinical Ophthalmology. 2021:1677–83.
32.
Koizumi T, Tanaka T, Umeda K, Komiyama D, Obata H. Correlation between extraocular muscle enlargement and thyroid autoantibodies in thyroid eye disease. Jpn J Ophthalmol. 2024;68:250–8.
33.
Xiong C, Ren Z, Li X, Jin Q, Wang S, Gan P, et al. Orbital computed tomography imaging characteristics of thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy. Scientific Reports. 2024;14:28960.
34.
Kaur S, Dogra M, Sukhija J, Dogra MR. Silicone band loop myopexy for myopic strabismus fixus. Indian Journal of Ophthalmology. 2019;67:1155–7.
35.
Enzmann D, Marshall Jr WH, Rosenthal AR, Kriss JP. Computed tomography in Graves' ophthalmopathy. Radiology. 1976;118:615–20.
36.
Gatt S, Mizzi A, Zarb F. Myopic Strabismus Fixus (Heavy eye syndrome (HES)) as a cause of intermittent diplopia. 2020.
Tables:
Table (1): Demographic characteristics of the studied patients
Table (2): Distribution of the studied patients according to different parameters including clinical presentation, etiology, and other associated conditions
Table (3): Distribution of the studied patients according to CT features of extra-ocular muscle involvement and associated orbital findings
Table (4): CT evaluation of the studied patients according to orbital fractures, extra-ocular muscle tears, and related orbital or paranasal findings
Figures Legends
 
No.
%
Sex
  
Female
12
30.0
Male
28
70.0
Age (years)
  
Min. – Max.
16.0–50.0
Mean ± SD
29.9 ± 10.28
Median
29.0
Data are expressed as number (No.) and percentage (%) unless otherwise specified. Age is given as mean ± standard deviation (SD), median, and range.
Tables (2): Distribution of the studied patients according to different parameters (n = 40)
 
No.
%
Complaint
  
Right lost medial rectus
3
7.5
Right strabismus
3
7.5
Left strabismus
12
30.0
Left myopic strabismus fixus
9
22.5
Bilateral myopic strabismus fixus
3
7.5
Divergent squint
3
7.5
Vertical squint
5
12.5
Thyroid ophthalmopathy
2
5.0
Onset (Onset diplopia)
  
Slow
28
70.0
Acute
12
30.0
Associated Clinical Conditions (DM/HTN)
  
No
38
95.0
Hyperthyroidism
2
5.0
Category
  
Traumatic
21
52.5
Non traumatic
19
47.5
Duration
  
Old
28
70.0
Recent
12
30.0
Cause
  
Blunt trauma to orbit
21
52.5
Myopia
9
22.5
Isolated
8
20.0
Thyroid ophthalmopathy
2
5.0
Values represent number (No.) and percentage (%). “Slow” onset indicates diplopia of gradual onset ≥ 1 month; “Acute” onset indicates diplopia within < 1 month. DM = diabetes mellitus; HTN = hypertension.
Tables (3): Distribution of the studied patients according to different parameters (n = 40)
 
No.
%
Side
  
Left
21
52.5
Right
11
27.5
Bilateral
8
20.0
Which Muscle
  
Both lateral rectus - superior rectus
6
15.0
Inferior rectus
11
27.5
Lateral rectus
3
7.5
Medial rectus
9
22.5
Superior oblique
11
27.5
Morphology of muscle involvement
  
Detachment/Disinsertion
6
15.0
Displacement
3
7.5
Displacement / Stretching
3
7.5
Full Thickness tear
3
7.5
Hypertrophy
2
5.0
Thinning
3
7.5
Thinning/Atrophy
20
50.0
Associated Findings
  
Blow out floor
6
15.0
Blow out medial wall
3
7.5
enlarged both globes
8
20.0
Hazy Orbital Fat
3
7.5
calcified trochleas
2
5.0
None
15
37.5
CT Findings
  
Thinning/Atrophy
20
50.0
Full thickness Tear
3
7.5
Detachment/Disinsertion
9
22.5
Hypertrophy/Thickening
3
7.5
Tendon
5
12.5
No. and % denote number and percentage of patients. EOM = extra-ocular muscle. “Thinning/Atrophy” refers to reduced cross-sectional area on CT compared with the contralateral side. Associated findings include orbital wall fractures and other structural changes detected on CT.
Tables (4): Distribution of the studied patients according to different parameters (n = 40)
 
No.
%
Site of fracture
  
No fracture
31
77.5
Medial wall
3
7.5
Comminuted inferior blow out fracture
3
7.5
Posterior 1 orbital floor fracture / blow out fracture
3
7.5
Other associated fracture
  
No
37
92.5
Fracture 1 nasal bone
3
7.5
Muscle tear
  
No
31
77.5
Yes
9
22.5
Site of tear (n = 9)
  
Anterior and posterior
3
33.3
At trochlea
3
33.3
Posterior part of muscle
3
33.3
Type of tear (n = 9)
  
Disinsertion
3
33.3
Full Thickness flap tear
6
66.7
Optic Nerve
  
Intact
40
100.0
Associated Orbital Findings
  
No
31
77.5
Preseptal edema
3
7.5
Entrapment of orbital fat within fracture gap
6
15.0
Adjacent PNS
  
Free
29
72.5
Sinusitis
11
27.5
Extra Orbital Findings
  
No
37
92.5
Prenasal edema
3
7.5
Prior Operations
  
No
37
92.5
Yes
3
7.5
Name of operation
  
No
37
92.5
Mini plate repair of anterrior orbital floor
3
7.5
No. and % denote number and percentage of patients. Site and type of tear are reported for the 9 patients with confirmed extra-ocular muscle tears. PNS = paranasal sinuses.
Figure-1
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(a)
(b)
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(c)
(d)
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(e)
(f)
Figure-2
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(a)
(b)
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(c)
(d)
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(e)
(f)
Figure-3
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(a)
(b)
Click here to download actual image
(c)
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(d)
(e)
Click here to download actual image
(f)
Figure-(4)
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(a)
(b)
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(c)
(d)
Click here to download actual image
(e)
Figure 5
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(a)
(b)
(c)
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(d)
(e)
Click here to download actual image
Click here to download actual image
(f)
(g)
Total words in MS: 4999
Total words in Title: 19
Total words in Abstract: 188
Total Keyword count: 7
Total Images in MS: 0
Total Tables in MS: 9
Total Reference count: 36