XinyangRen1Email960913532@qq.com
FanYang1✉Emailyangfan33@mail.sdu.edu.cn
LihuiMiao1
JiWang1
LuZhang1Email791660132@qq.comEmailgqwty168@163.com
XinYan1
HanYan1
TianyiWang1EmailQingyiyuan26@hotmail.com
11ï¿¿School of HistoryCapital Normal University100020BeijingChina
2Centre for Archaeology100020BeijingChina
3Kizil Grottoes Research Institute842300BaichengChina
44ï¿¿Yangtze University434020JingzhouChina
55ï¿¿School of Archaeology and MuseologySichuan University610200ChengduChina
Xinyang Renz,2*, Fan Yang2*✉, Lihui Miao3, Ji Wang3, Lu Zhang2, Xin Yan2, Han Yan4, Tianyi Wang5✉
1、School of History, Capital Normal University,Beijing,100020, China,960913532@qq.com
2、National Centre for Archaeology, Beijing,100020, China,yangfan33@mail.sdu.edu.cn
3、Xinjiang Kizil Grottoes Research Institute, Baicheng,842300, China,791660132@qq.com
z,2These authors contributed equally to this work and should be considered co-first authors
A
Corresponding author:
Tianyi Wang༚gqwty168@163.com,
Fan Yang༚yangfan33@mail. sdu.edu.cn
4、Yangtze University, Jingzhou, 434020, China, Qingyiyuan26@hotmail.com.
5、School of Archaeology and Museology, Sichuan University, Chengdu, 610200, China, gqwty168@163.com,
A
Abstract
Taitai’er Caves is an important part of the Kuča Caves, but the material and cultural life of the monks in the Hinayana Buddhist grottoes during the Sui and Tang dynasties is less explored at present. This paper explores the monks' utilization of grains, fruits and vegetables based on the remains of twelve types of grain crops(wheat, corn, millet, barley), fruit and vegetable crops, and field weeds unearthed from the Taitai’er Caves in Baicheng County, Xinjiang, in conjunction with the Hinayana Buddhist scriptures and unearthed documents. Through analysis, it is found that it adopted a multi—crop farming strategy in Taitai’er Caves. The monks used cheaper barley, millet, and corn as the main food. In addition, apricots, peaches, grapes, walnuts, gourds and other fruits and vegetables are also important dietary supplements in their daily lives.
A
Author Contribution
Xinyang Ren : Writing – original draft.Fan Yang: Writing – original draft, Software,Methodology, Data curation. Lihui Miao: Resources.Ji Wang: Writing – original draft,Resources. Lu Zhang: Formal analysis.Han Yan:Resources.Xin Yan: Data curation. Tianyi Wang: Visualization, Resources, Methodology.
1.Introduction
The Sui and Tang dynasties (581–907), a golden age for the development of Buddhism in China, saw the influence of religion beyond mere belief, it became the core force that supported the political operation of the dynasty, shaped the social structure and led cultural innovation. Buddhism was granted the special status of "
Gua rdian of the State and Upholder of Dharma" (护国正法) at the beginning of the Sui dynasty. Emperor Wen of Sui (Yang Jian), because of his special experience of sheltering in the Buddhist temple at an early age, after his accession to the throne, decreed upon his accession: "
The people in the territory were allowed to become monks, but still ordered people to give money to build Buddhist scriptures" (诏境内之民任听出家, 仍令计口出钱, 营造经像)
. This kind of political and religious linkage reached a new height in the Tang dynasty. Notably, such political utilization was not merely symbolic but institutionalized—Emperor Xuanzong set up the office of
Commissioner of Merits (功德使) to specialize in Buddhist affairs, the management of monks and the supervision of monasteries were incorporated into the bureaucratic system. This institutionalization underscored Buddhism's distinctive position within the imperial administrative framework.
A
Kuča, as a pivotal hub on the Silk Road,was not only the intersection of ancient india, Greco-Roman, Persia, and Han-Tang China, but also the center of the westward spread of Theravada Buddhism.
The Book of Jin (晋书) records that Kuča had a thousand pagodas and temples
and even more than 100 Buddhist temples and 5,000 monks
. In this context, Kuča monastery not only had the dual authority of politics and religion, but also became an important participant in social economy. The royal family deeply tied Buddhism to the monarchy through large-scale land donations, funding for grottoes (e.g, Kizil Grottoes) and monastery construction (e.g, Subashi/Babushka Temple).Through the granting of land by the crown, the worship of the faithful and self-cultivation, the monasteries became the landowners. They generated revenue by leasing fields to tenant farmers and engaging in agricultural product processing activities. This production process provided livelihood opportunities for some temple servants and lower-ranking monks and alleviated the social burden
.This economic model not only supports the operation of the temple itself, but also enables monasteries to influence social reproduction through disaster relief, loans and other charitable interventions
.
Within the agricultural-centric economic framework of Buddhist monasteries, the agricultural development pattern has become a window to observe the temple economy. Based on the collation of unearthed documents and historical documents in Xinjiang, current research believes that the temple economy in ancient Xinjiang was mainly based on agricultural cultivation, with monasteries owning farmland, orchards, gardens, and corresponding handicraft industries. Beyond supplying market circulation, monastic agricultural products were chiefly allocated to in-temple consumption to sustain monks,
Zuoren(作人,temple employees or sharecerealpers) and tributes for Buddha
.
In addition to cereals, monastic horticulture flourished significantly during the Jin and Tang period
. At present, the research on monastic agriculture predominantly investigates landholdings' economic origins and management systems through textual records, while there are relatively few studies on the structure of agriculture and the food structure of monks. The lack of relevant excavation evidence makes it more difficult to discuss this issue. Although phytoarchaeology has achieved breakthroughs in archaeobotanical studies like Tuyoq Grattoes
and Kaiyuan Temple in Zhengding
, it has mostly focused on the analysis of the plant remains ontology without fully combining with the religious attributes of the temples to carry out comprehensive research.
This study leverages the archaeological excavation of Taitai'er Caves, where substantial plant remains were discovered in two monastic cells (vihāra), to reconstruct the utilization of plant resources and agricultural planting structures in Buddhist monasteries during the 6th to 8th centuries. Based on the analysis of these unearthed plant remains, we aim to reconstruct the dietary structure and agricultural production models of Theravada Buddhist monks, while examining the underlying monastic economy.
Site Background
A
The Taitai'er Caves site is located approximately 6 km northeast of Kizil Township, Baicheng County, Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region, and about 500 meters north of Taitai'er Village (Fig.
1). Baicheng County lies within a banded basin encircled by mountains, characterized by a temperate continental arid climate. The frost-free period ranges from 133 to 163 days annually, with an average annual sunshine duration of 2,789.7 hours and the annual average precipitation of 171.13 mm.
The Taitai'er caves extends approximately 400 meters east-west and 160 meters north-south, with an altitude of 1,254 meters (using Cave 13 as the datum point)
. Situated on cliffs(and slopes) of eastern and western hills along the southern foothills of the Eter Mountains, the Taitai'er Caves align north-south with the Kizil Caves(Kizil Township), located 7 km southeast of Kizil Caves. Dating to the flourishing period to early late phase of Kuča Caves (6th to 8th centuries), the site originally comprised 22 caves, of which 18 are currently numbered. The caves include central pillar caves (caitya), monastic cells (vihāra), square chambers, niche chambers, and irregular caves. Six caves (Nos. 5, 11, 13, 15, 16, and 17) remain relatively intact, with four preserving exquisite murals
. From 2022 to 2023, a rescue excavation was conducted jointly by the Kizil Caves Research institute and the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous institute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology.
2.Materials and Methods
A
The samples were collected during the archaeological excavation of the Taitai'er Caves. During the cleaning of K7 and K12, macrobotanical remains were found in the occupational layers. All the plant remains were collected and transported to the Archeaobotany Laboratory of the National Centre for Archaeology for classification and identification. Cereals and weeds were photographed and measured using the Zeiss M165 microscope, while fruit stones were photographed with an SLR camera and measured with vernier calipers. Species identification of seeds, fruit stones and other types of plant remains has been conducted by reference to modern specimens in the laboratory, previously published atlases, and comparative materials from other archaeological sites
.
To further clarify the chronology of the unearthed plant remains, selected plant remains were sent to the Radiocarbon Dating Laboratory at Peking university for radiocarbon dating. Additionally, to determine the provenance of the plant remains, other selected specimens were sent to the Strontium Isotope Laboratory at the university of Science and Technology of China for strontium isotope analysis.
3.Results
3.1Dating results
Seven carbonized plant remains samples from layers K7, along with one sample from layer K12, were selected for radiocarbon dating. The results (Fig.
2) were calibrated using the intCal20 atmospheric curve
. The dating results for K7 show that its age can be divided into two periods. The first period was between 650-800AD, and the second period was after 800AD. The first period was when the grotto was in use, and the second period was when the grotto was abandoned and debris accumulated.
K12 was between 500–600AD, it is precisely the period when the grotto was in use.
3.2Plant remains
A total of 12 types of plant remains were identified at Taitai'er Caves (Table 1), which can be categorized into three categories: cereal, fruits and weeds. The cereal remains include wheat, foxtail millet, broomcorn millet, and barley (Fig. 3). in terms of quantity, broomcorn millet predominated: 64 intact grains were recovered from K7, while abundant husks( mostly fragmented) were founded in K7 and K12. Although these husks could not be fully quantified, they nevertheless clearly indicate broomcorn millet as the primary cereal. barley ranked second, with 1,001 grains (partially hulled). wheat and foxtail millet were scarce.There are five species of fruits (Armeniaca vulgaris, Amygdalus persica, Vitis vinifera, Juglans regia and Lagenaria siceraria)(Fig. 4), of which Armeniaca vulgaris significantly outnumbered other fruits. Sphaerophysa DC., Iris lactea pall. var. Chinensis and Xanthium sibiricum each represented by only 1 seed.
Table 1
Identification results of plant remains from Taitai'er Caves
Species Sites | K12 使用 | K7:93 使用 | K7:92 使用 | K7:89 废弃 | K7:99 废弃 | K7:112废弃 |
|---|
Hordeum vulgare | | | 1001 grains | | | |
Panicum miliaceum | Abundant chaff (uncountable) | | 64 grains | | Abundant chaff (uncountable) | |
Setaria italica | | | 6 grains | | | |
Triticum aestivum | | | 1 grain | | | |
Armeniaca vulgaris | | 206 stones | | | 1 stone | 316 stones |
Amygdalus persica | | 3 stones | | | | 1 stone |
Juglans regia | | 8 fragments (damaged) | | | | 1 stone |
Vitis vinifera | | | 3 seeds | | | |
Lagenaria siceraria | | | | 1 seed | | |
Iris lactea Pall. var. chinensis | | | 1 seed | | | |
Xanthium sibiricum | | | 1 seed | | | |
Sphaerophysa DC. | | | 1 seed | | | |
3.3Strontium Isotope Results
To investigate the provenance of plant remains and further study monastic agricultural economies, we selected five uncarbonized plant remains samples from K7, along with one sample from layer K12, for strontium isotope analysis. The ⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr ratios for different plant species are presented in Table 2.
Table 2
Strontium isotope results of plant remains from Taitai'er Caves
Lab no. | Context | Species | ⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr | SE (Standard Error) | Sr Concentration (ppb) |
|---|
ZY—13230 | K7 | Walnut | 0.710773 | 0.0000361425098261621 | 1326 |
ZY—13231 | K7 | Peach stone | 0.711246 | 0.0000393855444961329 | 1837 |
ZY—13232 | K7 | Apricot stone | 0.710698 | 0.0000467137023208503 | 933 |
ZY—13233 | K7 | Apricot stone | 0.710512 | 0.0000471509566275981 | 3455 |
ZY—13234 | K7 | Broomcorn millet chaff | 0.710923 | 0.0000838854079857661 | 108 |
ZY—13235 | K12 | Broomcorn millet chaff | 0.711003 | 0.0000674446832068956 | 123 |