A
A
Taitai'er Caves Plant Remains: Implications for Theravada Monastic Diets in Kucha
XinyangRen1Email
FanYang1✉Email
LihuiMiao1
JiWang1
LuZhang1EmailEmail
XinYan1
HanYan1
TianyiWang1Email
11ï¿¿School of HistoryCapital Normal University100020BeijingChina
2Centre for Archaeology100020BeijingChina
3Kizil Grottoes Research Institute842300BaichengChina
44ï¿¿Yangtze University434020JingzhouChina
55ï¿¿School of Archaeology and MuseologySichuan University610200ChengduChina
Xinyang Renz,2*, Fan Yang2*✉, Lihui Miao3, Ji Wang3, Lu Zhang2, Xin Yan2, Han Yan4, Tianyi Wang5
1、School of History, Capital Normal University,Beijing,100020, China,960913532@qq.com
2、National Centre for Archaeology, Beijing,100020, China,yangfan33@mail.sdu.edu.cn
3、Xinjiang Kizil Grottoes Research Institute, Baicheng,842300, China,791660132@qq.com
z,2These authors contributed equally to this work and should be considered co-first authors
A
Corresponding author: Tianyi Wang༚gqwty168@163.com, Fan Yang༚yangfan33@mail. sdu.edu.cn
4、Yangtze University, Jingzhou, 434020, China, Qingyiyuan26@hotmail.com.
5、School of Archaeology and Museology, Sichuan University, Chengdu, 610200, China, gqwty168@163.com,
A
Abstract
Taitai’er Caves is an important part of the Kuča Caves, but the material and cultural life of the monks in the Hinayana Buddhist grottoes during the Sui and Tang dynasties is less explored at present. This paper explores the monks' utilization of grains, fruits and vegetables based on the remains of twelve types of grain crops(wheat, corn, millet, barley), fruit and vegetable crops, and field weeds unearthed from the Taitai’er Caves in Baicheng County, Xinjiang, in conjunction with the Hinayana Buddhist scriptures and unearthed documents. Through analysis, it is found that it adopted a multi—crop farming strategy in Taitai’er Caves. The monks used cheaper barley, millet, and corn as the main food. In addition, apricots, peaches, grapes, walnuts, gourds and other fruits and vegetables are also important dietary supplements in their daily lives.
A
Author Contribution
Xinyang Ren : Writing – original draft.Fan Yang: Writing – original draft, Software,Methodology, Data curation. Lihui Miao: Resources.Ji Wang: Writing – original draft,Resources. Lu Zhang: Formal analysis.Han Yan:Resources.Xin Yan: Data curation. Tianyi Wang: Visualization, Resources, Methodology.
1.Introduction
The Sui and Tang dynasties (581–907), a golden age for the development of Buddhism in China, saw the influence of religion beyond mere belief, it became the core force that supported the political operation of the dynasty, shaped the social structure and led cultural innovation. Buddhism was granted the special status of "Gua rdian of the State and Upholder of Dharma" (护国正法) at the beginning of the Sui dynasty. Emperor Wen of Sui (Yang Jian), because of his special experience of sheltering in the Buddhist temple at an early age, after his accession to the throne, decreed upon his accession: "The people in the territory were allowed to become monks, but still ordered people to give money to build Buddhist scriptures" (诏境内之民任听出家, 仍令计口出钱, 营造经像). This kind of political and religious linkage reached a new height in the Tang dynasty. Notably, such political utilization was not merely symbolic but institutionalized—Emperor Xuanzong set up the office of Commissioner of Merits (功德使) to specialize in Buddhist affairs, the management of monks and the supervision of monasteries were incorporated into the bureaucratic system. This institutionalization underscored Buddhism's distinctive position within the imperial administrative framework.
A
Kuča, as a pivotal hub on the Silk Road,was not only the intersection of ancient india, Greco-Roman, Persia, and Han-Tang China, but also the center of the westward spread of Theravada Buddhism. The Book of Jin (晋书) records that Kuča had a thousand pagodas and temples and even more than 100 Buddhist temples and 5,000 monks. In this context, Kuča monastery not only had the dual authority of politics and religion, but also became an important participant in social economy. The royal family deeply tied Buddhism to the monarchy through large-scale land donations, funding for grottoes (e.g, Kizil Grottoes) and monastery construction (e.g, Subashi/Babushka Temple).Through the granting of land by the crown, the worship of the faithful and self-cultivation, the monasteries became the landowners. They generated revenue by leasing fields to tenant farmers and engaging in agricultural product processing activities. This production process provided livelihood opportunities for some temple servants and lower-ranking monks and alleviated the social burden.This economic model not only supports the operation of the temple itself, but also enables monasteries to influence social reproduction through disaster relief, loans and other charitable interventions.
Within the agricultural-centric economic framework of Buddhist monasteries, the agricultural development pattern has become a window to observe the temple economy. Based on the collation of unearthed documents and historical documents in Xinjiang, current research believes that the temple economy in ancient Xinjiang was mainly based on agricultural cultivation, with monasteries owning farmland, orchards, gardens, and corresponding handicraft industries. Beyond supplying market circulation, monastic agricultural products were chiefly allocated to in-temple consumption to sustain monks, Zuoren(作人,temple employees or sharecerealpers) and tributes for Buddha.
In addition to cereals, monastic horticulture flourished significantly during the Jin and Tang period. At present, the research on monastic agriculture predominantly investigates landholdings' economic origins and management systems through textual records, while there are relatively few studies on the structure of agriculture and the food structure of monks. The lack of relevant excavation evidence makes it more difficult to discuss this issue. Although phytoarchaeology has achieved breakthroughs in archaeobotanical studies like Tuyoq Grattoes and Kaiyuan Temple in Zhengding, it has mostly focused on the analysis of the plant remains ontology without fully combining with the religious attributes of the temples to carry out comprehensive research.
This study leverages the archaeological excavation of Taitai'er Caves, where substantial plant remains were discovered in two monastic cells (vihāra), to reconstruct the utilization of plant resources and agricultural planting structures in Buddhist monasteries during the 6th to 8th centuries. Based on the analysis of these unearthed plant remains, we aim to reconstruct the dietary structure and agricultural production models of Theravada Buddhist monks, while examining the underlying monastic economy.
Site Background
A
The Taitai'er Caves site is located approximately 6 km northeast of Kizil Township, Baicheng County, Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region, and about 500 meters north of Taitai'er Village (Fig. 1). Baicheng County lies within a banded basin encircled by mountains, characterized by a temperate continental arid climate. The frost-free period ranges from 133 to 163 days annually, with an average annual sunshine duration of 2,789.7 hours and the annual average precipitation of 171.13 mm.
The Taitai'er caves extends approximately 400 meters east-west and 160 meters north-south, with an altitude of 1,254 meters (using Cave 13 as the datum point). Situated on cliffs(and slopes) of eastern and western hills along the southern foothills of the Eter Mountains, the Taitai'er Caves align north-south with the Kizil Caves(Kizil Township), located 7 km southeast of Kizil Caves. Dating to the flourishing period to early late phase of Kuča Caves (6th to 8th centuries), the site originally comprised 22 caves, of which 18 are currently numbered. The caves include central pillar caves (caitya), monastic cells (vihāra), square chambers, niche chambers, and irregular caves. Six caves (Nos. 5, 11, 13, 15, 16, and 17) remain relatively intact, with four preserving exquisite murals. From 2022 to 2023, a rescue excavation was conducted jointly by the Kizil Caves Research institute and the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous institute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology.
Fig. 1
The geographical location of Taitai'er Caves in Kuča.
Click here to Correct
2.Materials and Methods
A
The samples were collected during the archaeological excavation of the Taitai'er Caves. During the cleaning of K7 and K12, macrobotanical remains were found in the occupational layers. All the plant remains were collected and transported to the Archeaobotany Laboratory of the National Centre for Archaeology for classification and identification. Cereals and weeds were photographed and measured using the Zeiss M165 microscope, while fruit stones were photographed with an SLR camera and measured with vernier calipers. Species identification of seeds, fruit stones and other types of plant remains has been conducted by reference to modern specimens in the laboratory, previously published atlases, and comparative materials from other archaeological sites.
To further clarify the chronology of the unearthed plant remains, selected plant remains were sent to the Radiocarbon Dating Laboratory at Peking university for radiocarbon dating. Additionally, to determine the provenance of the plant remains, other selected specimens were sent to the Strontium Isotope Laboratory at the university of Science and Technology of China for strontium isotope analysis.
3.Results
3.1Dating results
Seven carbonized plant remains samples from layers K7, along with one sample from layer K12, were selected for radiocarbon dating. The results (Fig. 2) were calibrated using the intCal20 atmospheric curve. The dating results for K7 show that its age can be divided into two periods. The first period was between 650-800AD, and the second period was after 800AD. The first period was when the grotto was in use, and the second period was when the grotto was abandoned and debris accumulated.
K12 was between 500–600AD, it is precisely the period when the grotto was in use.
Fig. 2
Calibrated radiocarbon dates of plant remains from Taitai'er Caves
Click here to Correct
3.2Plant remains
A total of 12 types of plant remains were identified at Taitai'er Caves (Table 1), which can be categorized into three categories: cereal, fruits and weeds. The cereal remains include wheat, foxtail millet, broomcorn millet, and barley (Fig. 3). in terms of quantity, broomcorn millet predominated: 64 intact grains were recovered from K7, while abundant husks( mostly fragmented) were founded in K7 and K12. Although these husks could not be fully quantified, they nevertheless clearly indicate broomcorn millet as the primary cereal. barley ranked second, with 1,001 grains (partially hulled). wheat and foxtail millet were scarce.There are five species of fruits (Armeniaca vulgaris, Amygdalus persica, Vitis vinifera, Juglans regia and Lagenaria siceraria)(Fig. 4), of which Armeniaca vulgaris significantly outnumbered other fruits. Sphaerophysa DC., Iris lactea pall. var. Chinensis and Xanthium sibiricum each represented by only 1 seed.
Fig. 3
Plant remains unearthed from Taitai'er Caves. 1.Hulled barley(Hordeum vulgare), 2.barley, 3.wheat, 4.Hulled broomcorn millet, 5.broomcorn millet, 6.Hulled foxtail millet, 7.foxtail millet, 8.apricot, 9.peach, 10–11.walnut.
Click here to Correct
Table 1
Identification results of plant remains from Taitai'er Caves
Species
Sites
K12
使用
K7:93
使用
K7:92
使用
K7:89
废弃
K7:99
废弃
K7:112废弃
Hordeum vulgare
  
1001 grains
   
Panicum miliaceum
Abundant chaff (uncountable)
 
64 grains
 
Abundant chaff (uncountable)
 
Setaria italica
  
6 grains
   
Triticum aestivum
  
1 grain
   
Armeniaca vulgaris
 
206 stones
  
1 stone
316 stones
Amygdalus persica
 
3 stones
   
1 stone
Juglans regia
 
8 fragments (damaged)
   
1 stone
Vitis vinifera
  
3 seeds
   
Lagenaria siceraria
   
1 seed
  
Iris lactea Pall. var. chinensis
  
1 seed
   
Xanthium sibiricum
  
1 seed
   
Sphaerophysa DC.
  
1 seed
   
3.3Strontium Isotope Results
To investigate the provenance of plant remains and further study monastic agricultural economies, we selected five uncarbonized plant remains samples from K7, along with one sample from layer K12, for strontium isotope analysis. The ⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr ratios for different plant species are presented in Table 2.
Table 2
Strontium isotope results of plant remains from Taitai'er Caves
Lab no.
Context
Species
⁸⁷Sr/⁸⁶Sr
SE (Standard Error)
Sr Concentration (ppb)
ZY—13230
K7
Walnut
0.710773
0.0000361425098261621
1326
ZY—13231
K7
Peach stone
0.711246
0.0000393855444961329
1837
ZY—13232
K7
Apricot stone
0.710698
0.0000467137023208503
933
ZY—13233
K7
Apricot stone
0.710512
0.0000471509566275981
3455
ZY—13234
K7
Broomcorn millet chaff
0.710923
0.0000838854079857661
108
ZY—13235
K12
Broomcorn millet chaff
0.711003
0.0000674446832068956
123
4.Discussion
Based on periodⅠquantitative analysis, broomcorn millet and barley emerged as the two most significant cereals among the plant remains discovered at Taitai'er Caves. Broomcorn millet exhibited the highest ubiquity, while foxtail millet and wheat were relatively scarce. Although barleywas exclusively found in K7, its quantity (1,001 grains) vastly exceeded that of foxtail millet and wheat. All plant remains were recovered from K7 and K12, identified as monastic cells (vihāra) where monks resided and performed daily activities. Therefore, these remains directly reflect monastic dietary practices. This evidence indicates a dietary preference among Taitai'er monks for broomcorn millet and barley, supplemented minimally by foxtail millet and wheat. In the periodⅡ, A large number of broomcorn millet husks were still found, indicating that broomcorn millet remained a very important crop even after the caves were abandoned.
The predominance of broomcorn millet and barley in Theravada Buddhist monastic contexts signifies an active adaptation to local environmental constraints. There is a typical temperate continental arid climate, with an average temperature of 7.6°C, frost-free period of 133 to 163 days, annual sunshine duration of 2,789.7 hours and annual precipitation of 171.13 mm. Within this environmental framework, cold and drought tolerance became critical determinants for crop planting selection. According to the climatic conditions of Luntai in the Tang dynasty, the crop growth period in this area was from the end of April to the middle of October. Barley and broomcorn millet, with superior stress tolerance, lower thermal requirements and minimal water demands, thrived under these conditions(Table 3). Their flowering and fruiting stages coincided with the rainy season, eliminating the need for intensive irrigation. Additionally, their shorter growth cycles provided an advantage over wheat, which cultivated from March to June, yielded poorly due to temperature limitations.
In archaeobotanical studies of the southern piedmont of the Tianshan Mountains (Table 4), sites such as Yanghai, Aisikexiaer South,, and Yuergou exhibit a crop planting structure dominated by broomcorn millet and barley. Liushugou, Mohuzhahangoukou and Wubao, primarily cultivated barley, while Duogang and Subeixi focused on broomcorn millet. This indicates that drought-tolerant crops (broomcorn millet and barley) formed the core agricultural system in this region since the Bronze Age, adapting to the arid continental climate. A few sites near water sources—such as Xintala, adjacent to Bosten Lake—were able to cultivate wheat.
The Sui to Tang dynasties were in the third warm period in China, the climate was relatively humid and the water and heat conditions were improved. Consequently, foxtail millet and wheat became the preferred cereals in the southern Tianshan region. The Tuyugou site in the Turpan Basin relied primarily on broomcorn millet during the Northern Wei Dynasty. By the Wei-Jin to Tang periods, the Astana site shows evidence of foxtail millet and wheat co-dominance, facilitated by improved hydrothermal conditions. At the Karakhoja Cemetery (Tang Dynasty), the crop planting structure shifted decisively toward foxtail millet and wheat. In contrast, the Kuola site, located at the northeastern piedmont of the Tianshan Mountains, was constrained by higher altitude and poorer hydrothermal conditions. The only plant remains unearthed were broomcorn millet and barley. This divergence underscores how topography-driven hydrothermal variations critically shaped cereal selection across the Tianshan region(Table 4).
Both Taitai'er Caves (the Sui to Tang dynasties) and Tuyoq Grottoes(Northern Wei Dynasty) showed a distinct preference for broomcorn millet. However, the monks of Tuyoq Grottoes demonstrated a significant inclination toward wheat, likely influenced by natural geographical factors. Despite similar latitudes, Tuyoq Grottoes are situated in the Turpan Basin at an elevation of 80 meters above sea level—approximately 1,200 meters lower than Taitai'er Caves—resulting in vastly superior thermal conditions. Additionally, Karez (坎儿井, underground canals) in Turpan Basin provided stable agricultural water supply, creating more favorable hydrothermal conditions for wheat cultivation.
Archaeobotanical data from the Tang dynasty at the Kaiyuan Temple in Zhengding, Hebei Province, reveal a crop planting structure dominated by foxtail millet and broomcorn millet, with overwhelmingly predominant (173 grains of foxtail millet, 39 grains of broomcorn millet, 5 grains of wheat and 2 grains of barley). This contrasts sharply with the crop structure of Taitai'er Caves. under the background of relatively similar environmental conditions in the overall era, such divergence primarily may be related to the local microclimate differences and agricultural planting traditions caused by the natural geographical differences between the two places.
Zhengding Kaiyuan temple is located in the eastern plains in China. Research has shown that the average temperature of the winter from 601 to 820 was approximately 0.52°C higher than that of the present (1961–2000), and during the same period there is a rainy phase of nearly 200 years. It can be seen that hydrothermal condition is one of the most important prerequisites for the cultivation of foxtail millet and broomcorn millet in Kaiyuan temple. In contrast, Taitaier Caves is located in the intermontane basin. The terrain factors make its thermal conditions relatively poor and the climate of Xinjiang during the Sui and Tang dynasties is also quite different from that of Kaiyuan temple. From Southern and Northern dynasties to Sui dynasty (420–600 A.D.), the lower temperature in Xinjiang led to the decrease of glacial snowmelt water and the less precipitation limited the water supply. in the late Tang dynasty, the climate turned cold and dry. in addition, from the Southern and Northern dynasties to the end of the Tang dynasty (420–907 A.D.), there were significant cold or warm climate fluctuation. During the Sui and Tang dynasties, the climate in Xinjiang changed greatly, so it was more suitable for the survival of plants with strong stress tolerance, mainly millet and barley.
The agricultural tradition of the region can not be ignored. in the central plains, foxtail millet and broomcorn millet have been cultivated since the Neolithic age. By the pre-qin period, although a multi-crops planting system of "Five Grains" (foxtail millet, broomcorn millet, rice, wheat and soybean) was formed, foxtail millet and broomcorn millet remained overwhelmingly dominant,. During the Qin and Han dynasties, this millet-centric structure persisted. During the Wei, Jin, southern and northern dynasties, traditional millet agriculture had matured significantly.Although rice and wheat gained prominence in the Sui and Tang period, millet-centric agriculture continued to dominate,. Thus, the deep-rooted millet farming tradition in the Central Plains, where Kaiyuan Temple is located, exerted a strong inertial influence on the local crop plantingl selection.
Northwestern China, including Xinjiang, served as a critical hub for the eastward transmission of wheat and barley from West Asia. As early as the late Neolithic age(cal. 5000 BP), wheat and barley cultivation had begun in this region. At the Xintala site, wheat predated barley, reflecting the complexity of crop composition. The Gumugou cemetery relied on glacial snowmelt water to support early wheat cultivation. Starch grain analysis from Shirenzigou site in Balikun county confirmed that the nomadic groups adopted barley as the staple food in spring, which was adapted to the cool and humid climate at the eastern Tianshan foothills and had a short growing period. From the Iron Age to Han and Jin dynasties, agricultural diversification had advanced, with sophisticated processing techniques for wheat and barley. During the Tang Dynasty, the ancient Dahe City in Balikun county developed a crop planting structure dominated by barley and wheat, supplemented by pea and foxtail millet, while military farmers implemented farming strategies tailored to the cold climatic condition. Consequently, the long history of barley and wheat cultivation in Xinjiang reflects environmental adaptation. At Taitai'er Caves, barley thrived due to its stress tolerance (drought and cold resistance). Therefore, the large number of unearthed barley is the result of inheriting the local agricultural tradition and adapting to the environment.
Beyond environmental factors, the preference for barley and broomcorn millet in Taitai'er Caves may also be influenced by Theravada Buddhism. Theravada Buddhism emphasizes alms-begging (Pindapāta) and non-selectivity in food consumption(托钵乞食、不择饮食). The Theravada Buddhism advocates begging, this doctrine asked monks to accept any donated food without preference. Therefore, the eating habit of monks in Taitai'er Caves are closely related to the grain production and supply in Kuča. According to the wooden slips SI P/136B from the Russian collection༈俄藏木牍SI P/136B༉, the largest quantity of barley purchased was 553 dou༈斗༉,, indicating that the Kuča monastery had a great demand for barley. Barley straw is also an ideal building material, which is conducive to the construction of caves and other buildings. Inddition to edible functions, Documents Excavated at Turpan (III)(吐鲁番文书) mentioned that barley was ritually offered in worship of Heaven.
Taitai'r Caves are located in Kuča and served as a center of Theravada Buddhist in the Western Regions during the Tang dynasty. From emperors to commoners, donating and abolishing secular affairs, observing fasting, receiving scriptures and listening to Dharma, and forgetting tiredness.The agricultural practices revealed by plant remains unearthed in the Taitai'r Caves reflect a proactive adaptation strategy of Buddhist monasteries to support large numbers of non-productive populations amid arid environments. Moreover, the monastic diet dominated by broomcorn millet and barley epitomized a precise alignment with the oasis agro-economy.
Five kinds of fruit were found there: apricot (Armeniaca vulgaris), peach (Amygdalus persica), grape (Vitis vinifera), walnut(Juglans regia) and gourd(Lagenaria siceraria). Quantitatively, apricot dominated with 523 grains, followed by peach (4 grains), walnut (9 grains), grape (3 grains), and bottle gourd (1 grain). Apricots not only constituted the absolute majority of fruit remains but also exhibited the highest ubiquity (50%). Peach and walnut followed with a recovery rate of 33.33%. The Great Tang Records on the Western Regions (大唐西域记) in the record:" The kingdom of Kuča (屈支国) spans over 1,000 li (里) east-west and 600 li (里) north-south.……It is suitable for broomcorn millet and wheat, yields rice, and produces grapes, pomegranates, abundant pears, crabapples, peaches, and apricots". This indicates that during the Sui-Tang times, inhabitants of Kuča (modern Kuqa) recognized the nutritional value of fruit.
The total number of apricots unearthed in the caves occupies an absolute advantage, which should be closely related to its growth habit, fruit tree management, planting tradition and nutritional value. Apricot originated in Xinjiang and exhibits exceptional environmental adaptability, with extreme cold and drought resistance. Apricot trees require minimal management, 2–3 years of fruit, 4–5 years of high yield. Archaeological evidence confirms that apricots have a long history of cultivation in Xinjiang. Apricot remains have been unearthed at the Niya site, Astana Cemeteries and Tuyoq Grottoes in Xinjiang. Up to now, Kuqa White Apricot is a high-quality variety of apricot cultivation in China. According to chronological analysis, we found that during the Sui and Tang dynasties, apricots were always used by Buddhist monks. Apricot flesh is rich in β-carotene. It is widely cultivated here with high yield, in the midsummer fruit off-season, it was the preferred choice of monks to eat.
Charcoal analysis from K7 revealed that the monastic communities selectively used small branches of Populus sp, Willows and Fraxinus for fuel and no fruit tree detected. This suggests monastic communities avoided burning fruit trees, likely because orchard cultivation was integral to their economic system. Monks strategically preserved fruit trees for sustained food production rather than fuel consumption .
Theravada Buddhism strictly prohibits monks from engaging in farming activities. While monks were permitted to receive land owneship rights, they could not personally participate in cultivation. Instead, field labor was delegated to hiring laborers affiliated with the monastery. Monks obtained portions of grain cereals or collected land taxes. As stated in the Abhidharma-samuccaya-vyākhyā (阿毗达磨集异门足论): "Digging the earth with one's own hands" and "destroying living plants" were considered "offenses requiring censure". Similarly, the Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra (大般涅槃经) prohibited "eight impure practices", including:"Hoarding gold or silver, owning slaves/livestock, maintaining granaries, engaging in trade, farming and preparing food with one's own hands".
Beyond doctrinal constraints, the fact that Kuča monks did not engage in agriculture may also be related to their social status. According to The Great Tang Records on the Western Regions (大唐西域记), on the 15th day of each month and the lunar month-end, the king and ministers discussed state affairs, consulting eminent monks before announcing decisions. This highlights the high political standing of monastic elites in Kuča, potentially explaining their exemption from manual labor. Despite Theravada prohibitions on farming, abundant broomcorn millet husks discovered in K7 and K12 at Taitai'er Caves indicate monks likely engaged in dehusking within the monastery. Beyond food consumping, millet husks may have been repurposed—for example, stuffed into sacks placed at bed legs to prevent floor damage.
Strontium isotope analysis of plant remains from Taitai'er Caves confirms local cultivation of both cereals and fruits. The ratios of 87Sr/86Sr in river samples from Kuča are between 0.7102 and 0.7118, while the ratios of 87Sr/86Sr in walnuts and peach are 0.710773 and 0.711246, respectively, the 87Sr/86Sr ratios were 0.710698 and 0.710512 for apricot and 0.710929 and 0.711003 for broomcorn millet. This demonstrates uninterrupted cultivation of broomcorn millet in Kuča during the Sui and Tang dynasties, with all crops and fruits sourced locally.
The Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya (根本萨婆多部律摄) stipulates: "If monasteries possess fields, gardens or livestock, they should entrust hired laborers for cultivation. The monastery may collect land taxes or a share of cereals to support the sangha. Should hired laborers till the land themselves, all grains, vegetables and fruits produced become impure". This indicates that monks at Taitai'er Caves likely organized agricultural activities through hired laborers on monastic-owned farmlands, achieving self-sufficiency. By the Sui and Tang dynasties, agriculture in Kuča had matured significantly, with monastic production reaching advanced levels. Agricultural tools and iconographic evidence confirm that the agricultural productivity of monasteries is highly developed. Stone sickles dating to 1000–600 BC were discovered at the Kizil Cemetery in Baicheng County.
The Ox Ploughing Scene in the Five Realms Reincarnation Scene(五趣轮回图—牛耕图) of Cave 175 at Kizil Caves depicts a scene of two yoked oxen pulling a plough, with a farmer holding the plough handle and wielding a whip to drive the cattle. The Tilling Scene(五趣轮回图—耕作图) in the same Scene demonstrates the use of Kantuman (坎土曼,broad-bladed hoes) for cultivation in Kuča. Meanwhile, adjacent cave structures—including niche caves, irregular-shaped caves, cross-shaped caves, and storage caves—likely served as monastic granaries or warehouses. The discovery of farming tools, agricultural murals and storage caves indicates that Buddhist monasteries probably owned cultivated lands. By organizing efficient agricultural production, they achieved self-sufficiency and even utilized grain reserves to mitigate risks.
Developed agriculture formed the core of monastic economies, simultaneously providing the foundation for monasteries to fulfill their social functions. As Jacques Gernet observed in Buddhist Monasteries in Chinese Society from the Fifth to the Tenth Centuries: from the Southern and Northern Dynasties to the Sui and Tang Dynasties, monasteries accumulated land through imperial grants, lay donations (donating farmlands to monasteries), and land reclamation (e.g, Guoqing Temple in Tiantai Mountain reclaiming forested land). Dependent laborers (净人) attached to monasteries tilled these lands, with harvests sustaining monastic daily life and ritual activities. In addition, monasteries was involved in tea cultivation, fruit orcharding, animal husbandry and selective logging. Land constituted a vital component of monastic property, while agrarian production provided stable funding and raw materials for the development of handicrafts and commerce. in the process of production, monasteries engaged with surrounding communities through land leasing and labor hiring. Guided by the principles of universal salvation and merit accumulation, they participated in infrastructure projects like bridge and road construction, as well as social relief efforts. Thus, Buddhist monasteries emerged as integral pillars in ancient societies.
Analysis of plant remains from the Taitai'er Caves and related literature reveals that Theravada Buddhist monasteries in Kuča achieved a balance between religious precepts and material production. While Theravada doctrine strictly prohibits monks from engaging in farming—as stated in Volume 4 of the Abhidharma-samuccaya-vyākhyā(阿毗达磨集异门足论) that digging earth with one's own hands and destroying plants constitute offenses requiring public censure. However, strontium isotope analysis demonstrates that crops and fruits unearthed at the cave were locally cultivated in Kuča. Thus, monastic communities at Taitair likely hired labor for agricultural activities surrounding the monastery.
Situated at a crossroads of civilizations along the Silk Road, the monastic economy of Taitai'er Caves developed a unique adaptive model under dual constraints of ecological limitations and Theravada Buddhist precepts. Confined by the high-altitude, arid basin environment with poor hydrothermal conditions, monastic communities primarily relied on cereals with strong stress resistance: broomcorn millet and barley, supplemented by foxtail millet and wheat. Fruits such as apricot (Armeniaca vulgaris), peach (Amygdalus persica), grape (Vitis vinifera), walnut(Juglans regia) and gourd (Lagenaria siceraria) provided essential dietary diversification .
Bound by monastic doctrines prohibiting direct farming, most Buddhist monks in Kuča served primarily as managers of monastic agricultural production, relying on hired labors for fieldwork. Theravada Buddhist monks were largely confined to processing activities such as grain dehusking. Monasteries accumulated farmlands through land grants, devotee donations and reclamation initiatives, while also managing orchards—thus diversifying their economic structure. Strontium isotope analysis confirms that plant remains unearthed in Taitai'er Caves were locally cultivated. The persistent utilization of broomcorn millet during the Sui and Tang dynasties further attests to the integration of alms-begging tradition with localized supply mechanisms.
This study reconstructs the agriculture patterns and monastic dietary practices of Kuča Buddhist monasteries based on archaeobotanical evidence unearthed from Taitai'er Caves, offering new perspectives for understanding socio-economic role of Buddhist monasteries along the Silk Road. It should be noted, however, that the strontium isotope analysis in this research relies on a limited sample size. The conclusions drawn thus remain preliminary inferences. Future studies with expanded sample sizes would significantly enhance the validation of our findings.
Table 3
Comparative Growth Characteristics of foxtail millet, broomcorn millet, wheat and barley,.
cereal
Frost Resistance
Drought Tolerance
Accumulated Temperature Requirement
Growing Season
foxtail millet
Poor
Strong
1600–3000°C
July–September
broomcorn millet
None
Strong
1100–2600°C
July–September
wheat
Variable
Poor
1500–8000°C
March–June
barley
Moderate
Strong
> 1100°C
Late February–May
Table 4
Basic information of plant remains from sites in the southern piedmont of the Tianshan Mountains.
Period
Site
foxtail millet
broomcorn millet
wheat
barley
reference
1950 − 1550 BC
Xintala
 
 
1610 − 474 BC
Liu Shugou Ruins
   
 
1261-49 BC
Yanghai Cemetery
 
 
800 − 400 BC
Wupu Cemetery
 
770 − 221 BC
Duogang Cemetery
 
   
750 − 450 BC
South Aisikexiaer Cemetery
 
 
 
600 − 400 BC
Yuergou
 
360 BC- 67AD
Shengjindian Cemetery
  
350 BC
Subeixi
 
Northern Wei Dynasty
Tuyoq Grottoes
 
Jin and Tang dynasties
Astana Cemeteries
 
Tang Dynasty
Karakhoja Cemetery
 
 
Click here to download actual image
A
Figure 4 Strontium isotope comparison between Taitaier Grotto Temple and its surrounding area.
Abstract
Taitai’er Caves is an important part of the Kuča Caves, but the material and cultural life of the monks in the Hinayana Buddhist grottoes during the Sui and Tang dynasties is less explored at present. This paper explores the monks' utilization of grains, fruits and vegetables based on the remains of twelve types of grain crops(wheat, corn, millet, barley), fruit and vegetable crops, and field weeds unearthed from the Taitai’er Caves in Baicheng County, Xinjiang, in conjunction with the Hinayana Buddhist scriptures and unearthed documents. Through analysis, it is found that it adopted a multi—crop farming strategy in Taitai’er Caves. The monks used cheaper barley, millet, and corn as the main food. In addition, apricots, peaches, grapes, walnuts, gourds and other fruits and vegetables are also important dietary supplements in their daily lives.
1
References
Sima, G. (Song Dynasty) com; Hu, S.X. (Yuan Dynasty) annot. Comprehensive Mirror for Aid in Government (Zizhi Tongjian), 175. Complete Library of the Four Treasuries (Siku Quanshu) edition, 19.
2
Fang X.L. (Tang Dynasty) Book of Jin (Baina Edition), Biographies 67–97: The Four Barbarians,8.
3
Xuan,Z., Bian, J. (Tang Dynasty), trans. & annot. Ji, X.L. et al. Annotation on the Great Tang Dynasty Record of the Western Regions. 54( Zhonghua Book Company, 1985).
4
Zhao, Y. Economic Life in ancient Xinjiang Monasteries from Archaeological Discoveries (Master’s Thesis, Minzu university of China, 2021).
5
He, R. Buddhist Monastery Economy and Its influence: A Preliminary Study Sociological Research. 4,75–92(2007) .༈in Chinese༉
6
Gao, Q.A. & Suo. D. Dietary Practices in Official Monastic Feasts: A Study of Dunhuang Manuscript 3231. Dunhuang Research.3,60–74(1998).༈in Chinese༉
7
Xie, C.G. Monastic Horticulture in Jin-Tang Dynasties: Monastery Garden Cultivation from the 3rd to 10th Centuries, Journal of Chinese Social and Economic History.3, 1–7(1989) .༈in Chinese༉
8
Wang, L., Jing, L., Zhang, G. & Jiang H.E. Research on Agricultural Activities of Turpan During Jin to Tang Dynasties:Taking Crop Remains in Tuyugou Grottoes as An Example, Agricultural Archaeology.6, 20(2020).༈in Chinese༉
9
Li, R.et al. Iterative Variation of Human Staples Related to Climate–Society interactions in the North China Plain between the 7th and 19th Centuries, Archaeological and anthropological Sciences 16, (2024).༈in Chinese༉
10
Turpan Cultural Relics Bureau,Survey Report of Taital Grottoes,Turfanological Research 1, 7 (2010).
11
Zhang, A.F. Investigating Historical and Cultural Resources around the Tarim Basin, 980(Shanghai People's Publishing House, 2018).༈in Chinese༉
12
a.Guo, Q.Z. Illustrated Identification Guide to Weed Seeds (China Agriculture Press, 1998). ; b.Guan, G.Q.et al. Atlas of Weed Seeds (Science Press, 2000).; c.National Forestry and Grassland Administration ed. Seeds of Woody Plants in China (China Forestry Publishing House, 2003).; d. Liu, C.J., Jin, G.Y. & Kong, Z.C.eds. Archaeobotany: Seeds and Fruits. (Science Press, 2008).; e. Zhao, Z.J. Archaeobotany: Theories, Methods and Practices (Science Press, 2010).; f. Guo, Q.S. ed. True-Color Illustrated Guide to Seeds of Chinese Medicinal Plants. (Higher Education Press, 2011).
13
Reimer, P. et.al. The intCal20 Northern Hemisphere radiocarbon age calibration curve(0–55 cal kBP). Radiocarbon 62,༈2020༉.༈in Chinese༉
14
Li, J. The Climate of Luntai in the Tang Dynasty. Arid Land Geography 2, 48 (1986).
15
Zhao, M.Y. et al. Archaeobotanical Studies of the Yanghai Cemetery in Turpan, Xinjiang, China, Archaeological and anthropological Sciences 11,1146 (2019).
16
Zhang, G.L. et al. Investigation of the Diverse Plant Uses at the South Aisikexiaer Cemetery (similar to 2700–2400 years BP) in the Hami Basin of Xinjiang, Northwest China, Archaeological and anthropological Sciences 11, 704(2019).
17
Dong,W.M. Palaeodietary study on human and faunal remains from Broze-Iron Age Hami Basin and its subsistence implication, 60 (PhD thesis, Lanzhou university, 2016) .
18
Liu, X.Y. et al. Journey to the East: Diverse Routes and Variable Flowering Times for Wheat and Barley En Route to Prehistoric China. PLOS ONE 12, 8–12(2017) .
19
Dong,W.M. Palaeodietary study on human and faunal remains from Broze-Iron Age Hami Basin and its subsistence implication, 49 (PhD thesis, Lanzhou university, 2016) .
20
Dong, W.M. et al. Subsistence strategies of people from Chawuhu Culture in the middle of Tianshan Mountains: A case study of Mohuchahan site from Hejing County, Xinjiang. Quaternary Sciences 42,87(2022).
21
Schröder et al. Ancient DNA identification of domestic animals used for leather objects in Central Asia during the Bronze Age, The Holocene 26,1725(2016).༈in Chinese༉
22
Tian, D. Archaeobotanical Studies of the Eastern Tianshan Southern Region in the First Millennium BC: Focusing on the Shirenzigou Site Complex. 132(PhD thesis, Northwest university, 2018).
23
Guo, W. Archaeological Research on the Society of the Late Prehistoric Xinjiang. 447(Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House, 2012) .
24
Gong,Y.W. et al. Investigation of ancient noodles cakes and millet at the Subeixi Site,Xinjiang, China. Journal of Archaeological Science 38,472—473(2011).
25
Zhao, K.L.et al. Impact of agriculture on an oasis landscape during the late Holocene: Palynological evidence from the Xintala site in Xinjiang, NW China. Quaternary international 311, 83(2013).
26
Zhu, K.Z. A Preliminary Study on Climate Change in China over the Past Five Thousand Years. Scientia Sinica 3, 174(1973).
27
Jing, L., Wang, L.& Jiang, H.E. Research on Agricultural Activities of Turpan During Jin to Tang Dynasties:Taking Crop Remains in Tuyugou Grottoes as An Example. Agricultural Archaeology 1,16–21(2020).༈in Chinese༉
28
Chen, T.et al. Archaeobotanical Study of ancient Food and Cereal Remains at the Astana Cemeteries, Xinjiang, China. PLoS ONE 7, e45137(2012). ༈in Chinese༉
29
Zhang, Y. et al. Study on the Plant Remains from the Karakhoja Cemetery in Xinjiang from Jin to Tang Dynasties. Agricultural Archaeology 4, 7–14(2021) .༈in Chinese༉
30
Tian, D. Archaeobotanical Studies of the Eastern Tianshan Southern Region in the First Millennium BC: Focusing on the Shirenzigou Site Complex. 124(PhD thesis, Northwest university, 2018).༈in Chinese༉
31
Li.R.et al. Iterative variation of human staples related to climate–society interactions in the North China plain between the 7th and 19th centuries. Archaeological and anthropological Sciences 16,160(2024).
32
Ge, Q.S.et al. Reconstruction of temperature change in the eastern and central regions of China during the Sui and Tang Dynasties (601 ~ 920). Chinese Science Bulletin 31,3050(2010).༈in Chinese༉
33
Wang, C. &Wang, S.M. Changes in annual precipitation in the Central Plains of China over the past 5,000 years. Science in China Series B: Chemistry, Biology, Agricultural, Medical & Earth Sciences 17,111(1987). ༈in Chinese༉
34
Wang, H.P. et al. Climate change drove the route shifts of the ancient Silk Road in two distinct ways. Science Bulletin 69,1158–1169(2024).༈in Chinese༉
35
Ge, Q.S.et al. Climate Change in Chinese Dynastic History. 321(Science Press, 2011).
36
Wang, H.P. et al. Climate change drove the route shifts of the ancient Silk Road in two distinct ways. Science Bulletin 69, 1153–1160(2024).༈in Chinese༉
37
Zhong, H. et al. Preliminary research of the farming production pattern in the Central Plain area during the Miaodigou Period. Quaternary Sciences 40, 472–485(2020).
38
Wang, N. et al. A preliminary study of the multi-crops planting system in the central plains of the early Shang Dynasty: Taking the Wangjinglou site in Xinzheng of Henan as an example. Acta anthropologica Sinica 41, 105(2022). ༈in Chinese༉
39
Zhang, J.N., Xia, Z.K.& Zhang, X.H. Research on charred plant remains from the Neolithic to the Bronze Age in Luoyang Basin. Chinese Science Bulletin 59, 3392(2014).༈in Chinese༉
40
Xia, X.Y. et al. Development of diversified crop structure in the Guanzhong Plain revealed by carbonized plant remains from the Ducheng site, Xi’an. Quaternary Sciences 45, 260–261 (2025).༈in Chinese༉
41
Gao, P.P. Study on Staple Crops in the Zhengzhou Area during the Han and Tang Dynasties. 37–56(Master's thesis, Zhengzhou university, 2022).
42
Li, S.G.et al. Historical evolution and future development direction of foxtail millet cultivation in China. Science and Technology of Cereals, Oils and Foods 30 , 62(2022) .༈in Chinese༉
43
Li, F. et al. New discoveries of ancient agricultural remains at the Donghuishan Neolithic site in Minle County, Gansu Province. Agricultural Archaeology 1, 60–61(1989).༈in Chinese༉
44
Zhao, K.l.et al.Characteristics of agricultural activities and its impact on the environment at Xintala site, Xinjiang, reconstructed from archaeological plant remains. Quaternary Sciences 32, 219–225(2012).
45
Zhang, G.l. et al. Ancient plant use and palaeoenvironmental analysis at the Gumugou Cemetery, Xinjiang, China: implication from desiccated plant remains. Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences 9, 145–152(2017).
46
Tian, D., Ma, J., Wang, J.X. & Zhao, Z.J. Analysis of plant remains from Structure ⅢF1 at the Shirenzigou site, Balikun, Xinjiang. Archaeology and Cultural Relics 5, 126(2022).༈in Chinese༉
47
Wang, Q. et al. Microbotanical remains provide direct evidence for the functional study of stone tools from Jartai Pass site in Nilka County, Xinjiang. Quaternary Sciences 40,450–461(2020).
48
Dun,G.L. et al. Agricultural activities inferred by the charred plant seeds at ancient Dahe City, a Tang Dynasty military garrison site, Barkol County, Xinjiang. Quaternary Sciences 45,319–334(2025).
49
" The Buddha was in Varanasī. Five bhikkhus visited him, prostrated and asked: 'World-Honored One, what shall we eat?' The Buddha replied: 'You may beg for food.' They inquired again: 'What vessel should we use?' The Buddha said: 'You may use alms bowls.'" (Dīrgha Āgama, Chap. 22).Buddhajiva et al. (trans.) (Liu Song Dynasty) Mahīśāsaka Vinaya (Five-Part Vinaya), fascicle 22: Food Regulations, Part 3.8. (ed. Goryeo Tripitaka), 2.
50
Qing, Z.R. Tocharian Secular Texts and History of ancient Kucha. 149–150(Peking University Press, 2017).
51
Zhang, G.L.et al.Investigation of the diverse plant uses at the South Aisikexiaer Cemetery (similar to 2700 ~ 2400 years BP) in the Hami Basin of Xinjiang, Northwest China. Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences 11 ,707(2019).
52
This reflects a fixed monthly expenditure of five sheng of barley for celestial rituals, as documented in the Gaochang monastery ledger (625–626 CE). Barley, a staple crop, held both economic and religious significance in Turpan's oasis agriculture, by Tang Changru. (ed.) Documents Excavated at Turpan (III).225 (Cultural Relics Press, 1981).
53
Xuan, Z.& Bian, J.(Tang Dynasty), Ji, X.L. et al. (eds), Annotation on the Great Tang Dynasty Record of the Western Regions. 61(Zhonghua Book Company, 1985).
54
Xuan, Z.& Bian, J.(Tang Dynasty), Ji, X.L. et al. (eds), Annotation on the Great Tang Dynasty Record of the Western Regions. 54(Zhonghua Book Company, 1985).
55
Jia, J.X., Jia, D.X. & Ren, Q.M. (eds), Crops and Their Wild Relatives in China (Fruit Trees Volume). 173–177, 224–228, 337–344, 415–417(China Agriculture Press, 2006).
56
Shi, S.Q. Discussion on the Niya Site in Minfeng, Xinjiang. Cultural Relics Z2,25(1962).༈in Chinese༉
57
Chen, T. Archaeobotanical Research on the Astana ancient Tombs in Turpan. 24–46(PhD thesis, university of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2014).
58
Wang, L. et al. Study on the Remains of Horticultural Plants in Tuyoq Grottoes of Turpan. Agricultural Archaeology 6, 20(2020).༈in Chinese༉
59
Zhang, J.Y.& Zhang, Z. (eds). Monograph of Chinese Fruit Trees (Apricot Volume), 1–2(China Forestry Publishing House, 2003).
60
Yang,F.,Miao,L.H.& Wang,L. Wood from the 4th − 7th century CE in Kuˇca Caves in Xinjiang, China: Past vegetation and preliminary wood utilization, Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 68,(2025).
61
Such as karmic purifiers (客儿, ke'er), service personnel (使人, shi ren), and external laborers (外作人, wai zuoren) .
62
CBETA 2024.R3, T26, 1536, 381a7-11.
63
Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra. Taishō Tripiṭaka, 10, 1767, 96.
64
Xuan,Z.& Bian,J. (Tang Dynasty), Ji, X.L. et al. (eds), Annotation on the Great Tang Dynasty Record of the Western Regions, 61(Zhonghua Book Company,1985).
65
The bhikkhus made bed legs with sharp corners, which subsequently damaged the ground. The Buddha instructed: They should not be made sharp; they should be crafted flat. When damage still occurred, the Buddha further instructed: Place straw-stuffed bags beneath the bed legs, or wrap them with torn cloth strips. by Yi,J. (trans.) (Tang Dynasty) Mūlasarvāstivāda Vinaya Kṣudraka Vastu (Fundamental Sayings of All Existence: Miscellaneous Matters of the Vinaya), fascicle 13, 2(Fuzhou Tripitaka ed.)
66
Wang, X.Y., Tang, Z.H.& Dong, X.X. Distribution of strontium isotopes in river waters across the Tarim Basin: a map for migration studies. Journal of the Geological Society 175, 967–973(2018).
67
CBETA 2024.R2, T24, 1458, 558b10-16.
68
Guo, W. Archaeological Research on the Society of the Late Prehistoric Xinjiang. 447 (Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House, 2012).
69
Institute of Archaeology XinJiang Academy of Social Sciences, Thirty Years of Xinjiang Archaeology. appendix: Plate 290(Xinjiang People’s Publishing House, 1983).
70
Wubuli, M.M.T.A.L. Architectural Research on the Xinjiang Section of the Silk Road.༈Science Press, 2015༉.
71
Jacques,G. Buddhist Monasteries in Chinese Society: An Economic Perspective from the Fifth to the Tenth Centuries(Gansu People’s Publishing House,1987).
72
Twitchett & Denis, C. The Monasteries and China’s Economy in Medieval Times. Bulletin of the School of Oriental and African Studies 19, 526–549(1957). JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/609825. Accessed 31 Jan. 2025.
73
Kenneth, K. S. C.The Role of Buddhist Monasteries in Tang Society. History of Religions 15, 209–230(1976).
74
He, R. A Preliminary Study on Buddhist Monastery Economy and Its Societal Impact. Sociological Research 4 ,82(2007).༈in Chinese༉
Author contributions
Xinyang Ren and Fan Yang: Writing – original draft, Software, Formal analysis, Data
curation. Lihui Miao: Writing – original draft. Ji Wang: Writing – original draft. Lu Zhang : sample anaysis, Xin Yan: Data curation. Han Yan: sample anaysis. Tianyi Wang: Visualization, Resources, Methodology.
Funding
This research was supported by Sichuan University Double First-Class Initiative: Regional History & Frontier Ethnic Groups Funding Project.
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
75
Tian, D. Archaeobotanical Studies on the Region of East Tianshan Mountains in the First Millennium BC: Shirenzigou-centric Perspective ,168(PhD thesis, Northwest university, 2018).
76
Qing, Z. R.Tocharian Secular Texts and History of ancient Kucha,156–163(Peking University Press, 2017).
Total words in MS: 6582
Total words in Title: 11
Total words in Abstract: 133
Total Keyword count: 0
Total Images in MS: 3
Total Tables in MS: 5
Total Reference count: 0