Article: From Possibility to Probability:
Population-Genetic Accessibility of Enzyme Specialization After Gene
Duplication
Journal: Journal of Molecular Evolution
Author: Jordan A. Dowell
Affiliation: Department of Biological Sciences,
Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70803, USA
Correspondence: jdowell@lsu.edu
Archive version: 1.0.0 (2 November 2026)
Promiscuous enzymes can perform more than one reaction, but selection that improves one activity may reduce another. Gene duplication can resolve this catalytic conflict only if a new copy persists long enough for the two copies to diverge. These simulations separate that process into two population-genetic transitions: access to a retained two-copy state and specialization after retention.
This electronic supplement contains the exact two-reaction SLiM model
used in the paper, the exact portable base-R launch and validation
scripts, the frozen production design grids, and a small example design.
The canonical source files are preserved byte-for-byte.
MODEL_GUIDE.md provides the deeper annotation needed to
connect each code section to the biological questions addressed in the
manuscript.
| Path | Purpose |
|---|---|
model/duplication_invasion.slim |
Canonical SLiM 4.0.1 model for ancestral adaptation, duplicate introduction, invasion, retention, specialization, dosage, and mutation-fate tracking. |
MODEL_GUIDE.md |
Commented map of the model, launcher, parameters, phases, outcomes, and production contrasts. |
scripts/run_invasion_row.R |
Exact portable base-R launcher for one design row, used by array workflows. |
scripts/run_invasion_grid.R |
Exact restart-safe base-R launcher for a complete design grid, with optional local parallel workers. |
scripts/check_invasion_run.R |
Exact run-completeness and error-term check. |
config/ |
Frozen production CSVs used to construct the ancestral, retained-duplication, single-origin, and dosage experiments. |
examples/example_grid.csv |
Five short demonstration rows: one ancestral-state save, two retained-duplication treatments, and two single-origin treatments. |
examples/run_examples.sh |
Runs the example rows sequentially and stores outputs below
example_results/. |
examples/EXPECTED_OUTPUTS.md |
Describes the generated folders and columns without treating the small demonstration as a biological experiment. |
FILE_MANIFEST.tsv |
File purpose, paper component, byte count, and SHA-256 checksum. |
VERSION.txt |
Archive version and provenance. |
LICENSE |
MIT license for the scripts in this archive. |
run_examples.sh.The example runner searches for slim and
Rscript on PATH. Their locations can be
overridden without editing a file:
SLIM_BIN=/path/to/slim RSCRIPT_BIN=/path/to/Rscript sh examples/run_examples.sh
From the unpacked top-level directory, run:
sh examples/run_examples.sh
The first row adapts and saves a small ancestral population. The next four rows load that same state and compare compensated with additive dosage in two experiments:
duplication_intro_copies = 2N). This experiment asks what
evolves after access to the two-copy state is imposed.duplication_intro_copies = 1). This experiment asks
whether a rare new copy survives long enough to establish and
specialize.The example uses a small population and short phases only to verify installation and file generation. It is not expected to reproduce the publication estimates.
Rows with load_ancestral_state = TRUE require a state
bank created by the corresponding
paper1_ancestral_state_bank_*.csv grid. Each state has two
required files with the same identifier:
<ancestral_state_id>.slimbin, the binary SLiM
population state; and<ancestral_state_id>.effects.csv, the catalytic
effects associated with every segregating mutation.The two files must be placed together in
<output-root>/ancestral_states/. A
.slimbin file alone is insufficient because the catalytic
effects stored as simulation values must be restored from the
sidecar.
The population begins with one enzyme copy and adapts under selection
on two required catalytic activities. Each catalytic mutation changes
both activities. The correlation between those changes is determined by
relationship:
strong_antagonism: improving one reaction usually
reduces the other.weak_antagonism: the conflict remains, but mutational
effects are less strongly opposed.unconstrained: effects on the two reactions are
independent.weak_synergism: improvements in one reaction tend to
improve the other.strong_synergism: mutational effects on the two
reactions are strongly aligned.The paper used independently adapted ancestral populations and condition-specific burn-in lengths established by ensemble stationarity analyses. Saved population files and mutation-effect sidecars allowed matched post-duplication treatments to begin from the same evolved state.
At
duplication_intro_generation = burnin_generations + 1, the
model copies the catalytic state of the chromosome receiving the
duplication marker. A value of one for
duplication_intro_copies represents one new origin. A value
of 2N creates the retained-duplication contrast by placing
the marker on every chromosome.
compensated: total catalytic output is averaged across
present copies. The new copy therefore provides no immediate output
increase.additive: every gene copy contributes its full
activity. An otherwise identical heterozygous duplication begins with
nominal activity of 3/2 relative to the ancestral diploid, whereas a
duplication on both homologs begins with 4/2.These treatments bracket two mechanistic possibilities. They do not imply that all biological duplicates are completely compensated or completely additive.
The hard boundary excludes catalytic states outside the declared
feasible region. The soft boundary applies a continuous penalty whose
strength is controlled by soft_boundary_strength.
selection_strength scales the conversion from relative
catalytic performance to reproductive success. The manuscript evaluates
how these settings change both ancestral dynamics and post-duplication
accessibility.
The model records:
Persistent specialization requires both sufficient duplicate
frequency and specialization above the declared threshold for
persistence_generations. This distinguishes transient
catalytic separation from an outcome that remains present across
multiple event checks.
The production design used a population size of 1,000; per-position mutation rates of 10^-7 and 10^-6; mutation-effect standard deviation of 0.025; recombination rate of 10^-8; hard and soft boundaries (soft-boundary strength 100); selection-strength multipliers of 0.5, 1, and 2; zero direct duplication cost; and all five catalytic relationships. Condition-specific ancestral phases ranged from 10N to 60N generations, with 80N used for identified ridge-evolving treatments. Post-duplication phases were 10N generations, with a 20N duration sensitivity for ridge treatments.
Production estimates should be reproduced from the frozen design
manifests and random seeds described in the article’s data and code
availability statement. example_grid.csv intentionally uses
smaller values and is only an execution check.
The primary retained-duplication estimate of 56/300 combines three
compensated grids: paper1_retained_stationary_r20.csv,
paper1_retained_ridge_60N_r20.csv, and
paper1_retained_active_add30_r50.csv. This experiment uses
the validated condition-specific ancestral durations selected for the
primary analysis.
The matched dosage control of 61/1,140 uses
paper1_retained_stationary_r20.csv,
paper1_retained_ridge_80N_r20.csv, and
paper1_retained_active_add30_r50.csv, expanded across the
full matched dosage design. It is paired with
paper1_dosage_additive_retained.csv. The 60N primary ridge
treatment and 80N dosage-matched ridge treatment answer different
declared comparisons and must not be pooled.
The single-origin compensated analysis combines
paper1_single_origin_r20.csv with
paper1_single_origin_expansion_add4740.csv; the additive
matched treatment is in
paper1_dosage_additive_single_origin.csv.
The launcher requires these columns:
run_set, relationship,
replicate, seed, population_size,
generations, output_every,
event_check_every, mutation_rate,
mutation_step_sd, recombination_rate,
base_activity, selection_strength,
burnin_generations,
post_duplication_generations,
duplication_intro_generation,
duplication_intro_copies, duplication_cost,
establishment_frequency, fixation_frequency,
specialization_threshold,
persistence_generations, and
target_fitness_fraction.
Optional columns in the example activate boundary and dosage
treatments, ancestral-state reuse, early stopping, and origin
identifiers. Mutation-fate tracking requires the additional fields
checked in scripts/run_invasion_row.R.
FILE_MANIFEST.tsv provides checksums for
archive-integrity checks.Please cite the associated article when using this model. The scripts
are released under the MIT license in LICENSE. The
simulation design is documented in the manuscript and Online Resource 1;
this archive provides the executable implementation. File-level SHA-256
values in FILE_MANIFEST.tsv can be used to verify that the
canonical model, runners, and production grids have not changed.