Reproduction of the pigment evidence synthesis

Corpus: 107 publications to 14 August 2025; 157 evidence units, including 103 eligible direct-retrieval units from 53 publications. The 156 pigment mentions are separate, non-exclusive publication-level tags.

Alikas et al. (2023), unit 30-Chlorophylla: R3, TR = 1. Quantitative method comparison supports validated retrieval, but product-specific separation of coefficient fitting/selection from structured evaluation is not established. No random partition is inferred. Source locations and rationale are recorded in full_units157.csv. The main analysis adopts R3; there is no separate provisional Alikas scenario. Yala remains R4/TR2.

Main distribution: publications R1/R2/R3/R4/R5/R6 = 1/12/31/7/2/0; units = 1/24/56/19/3/0. Independent validation is the first unmet requirement in 56/103 units. Marginal unmet TR >= 2 = 75/103. Sensitivity: transfer relaxation gives 18 stage-5 units; joint relaxation gives 8 stage-5 and 10 stage-6 units.

Bernardo extracted the study information and classified the units. Caio verified extracted information and assessed units with the same framework. Classifications were compared and disagreements resolved through discussion and consensus, as described in the manuscript. No agreement coefficient or separate coder-rating matrix is supplied or generated by this package. Unit metadata retain the recorded scope of assessment and configuration-specific assistance.

Python 3.10+; standard library for numerical summaries; numpy and matplotlib for figures. Run from this directory:
 python sources_v5/recompute.py
 python sources_v5/sensitivity.py
 python output_v5/figures/make_figures.py
 python sources_v5/make_revision_figures.py
 python output_v5/figures/make_figure_s1.py

The first-unmet-gate counts are sequential; marginal requirements overlap. Relaxed scenario-stage numbers do not inherit the main rubric's cross-system and operational meanings. Multiple units within a publication are dependent. Arial is requested; Nimbus Sans is used and recorded when Arial is unavailable. Editable and outlined SVG exports are supported.
