Additional computed values outside the frozen 72-value comparison: 5
ok   gamma_pm_NaCl               RW reported                                    reported=0.935 recomputed=0.93531187 abs_diff=0.000311871 tolerance=0.002
ok   gamma_pm_NaCl               SW reported                                    reported=0.667 recomputed=0.66723982 abs_diff=0.000239823 tolerance=0.002
ok   gamma_pm_NaCl               RO brine reported                              reported=0.652 recomputed=0.65202418 abs_diff=2.41773e-05 tolerance=0.002
ok   ionic_strength_mol_kg       RW reported                                    reported=0.0037 recomputed=0.00368556 abs_diff=1.444e-05 tolerance=5e-05
ok   ionic_strength_mol_kg       SW reported                                    reported=0.699 recomputed=0.699029 abs_diff=2.9e-05 tolerance=0.002
ok   ionic_strength_mol_kg       RO brine reported                              reported=1.217 recomputed=1.21706 abs_diff=6e-05 tolerance=0.003
ok   charge_balance_error_pct    RW reported                                    reported=40.77 recomputed=40.803383 abs_diff=0.0333827 tolerance=0.1
ok   charge_balance_error_pct    SW reported                                    reported=9.18 recomputed=9.1828138 abs_diff=0.00281382 tolerance=0.05
ok   charge_balance_error_pct    RO brine reported                              reported=-3.55 recomputed=-3.5542747 abs_diff=0.00427474 tolerance=0.05
ok   gamma_pm_NaCl               RW Cl-balanced                                 reported=0.928 recomputed=0.92846323 abs_diff=0.000463226 tolerance=0.002
ok   gamma_pm_NaCl               SW Cl-balanced                                 reported=0.663 recomputed=0.66349659 abs_diff=0.000496593 tolerance=0.002
ok   gamma_pm_NaCl               RO brine Cl-balanced                           reported=0.653 recomputed=0.65258958 abs_diff=0.000410418 tolerance=0.002
ok   ionic_strength_mol_kg       RW Cl-balanced                                 reported=0.00465 recomputed=0.00465068 abs_diff=6.8e-07 tolerance=5e-05
ok   ionic_strength_mol_kg       SW Cl-balanced                                 reported=0.754 recomputed=0.75412 abs_diff=0.00012 tolerance=0.003
ok   ionic_strength_mol_kg       RO brine Cl-balanced                           reported=1.179 recomputed=1.17928 abs_diff=0.00028 tolerance=0.003
ok   gamma_pm_NaCl               RW HCO3-balanced                               reported=0.935 recomputed=0.93469538 abs_diff=0.000304616 tolerance=0.002
ok   share_pct                   SW/RW conductivity-equivalent activity         reported=17.2 recomputed=17.209265 abs_diff=0.00926531 tolerance=0.1
ok   share_pct                   SW/RW conductivity-equivalent membrane         reported=10 recomputed=9.9782961 abs_diff=0.0217039 tolerance=0.1
ok   share_pct                   SW/RW conductivity-equivalent residual         reported=72.8 recomputed=72.812439 abs_diff=0.0124386 tolerance=0.1
ok   share_pct                   SW/RW composition activity                     reported=11.4 recomputed=11.413164 abs_diff=0.0131644 tolerance=0.1
ok   share_pct                   SW/RW composition membrane                     reported=8 recomputed=7.9645261 abs_diff=0.0354739 tolerance=0.1
ok   share_pct                   SW/RW composition residual                     reported=80.6 recomputed=80.62231 abs_diff=0.0223095 tolerance=0.1
ok   share_pct                   RO-brine/RW conductivity-equivalent activity   reported=14.9 recomputed=14.874595 abs_diff=0.025405 tolerance=0.1
ok   share_pct                   RO-brine/RW conductivity-equivalent membrane   reported=17.8 recomputed=17.812408 abs_diff=0.0124077 tolerance=0.1
ok   share_pct                   RO-brine/RW conductivity-equivalent residual   reported=67.3 recomputed=67.312997 abs_diff=0.0129973 tolerance=0.1
ok   share_pct                   RO-brine/RW composition activity               reported=10.3 recomputed=10.309211 abs_diff=0.00921117 tolerance=0.1
ok   share_pct                   RO-brine/RW composition membrane               reported=14.8 recomputed=14.800263 abs_diff=0.000263106 tolerance=0.1
ok   share_pct                   RO-brine/RW composition residual               reported=74.9 recomputed=74.890526 abs_diff=0.00947428 tolerance=0.1
ok   ionic_strength_mol_L        RW reported (molarity)                         reported=0.00369 recomputed=0.003685 abs_diff=5e-06 tolerance=1e-05
ok   ionic_strength_mol_L        SW reported (molarity)                         reported=0.692 recomputed=0.6915 abs_diff=0.0005 tolerance=0.001
ok   ionic_strength_mol_L        RO brine reported (molarity)                   reported=1.192 recomputed=1.192 abs_diff=0 tolerance=0.001
ok   f_div                       RW                                             reported=0.507 recomputed=0.50678733 abs_diff=0.00021267 tolerance=0.001
ok   f_div                       SW                                             reported=0.127 recomputed=0.12695652 abs_diff=4.34783e-05 tolerance=0.001
ok   f_div                       RO brine                                       reported=0.119 recomputed=0.11928651 abs_diff=0.000286511 tolerance=0.001
ok   deficit_pct                 SW/RW conductivity-equivalent                  reported=37.5 recomputed=37.5 abs_diff=0 tolerance=0.05
ok   deficit_pct                 SW/RW composition                              reported=47.5 recomputed=47.5 abs_diff=0 tolerance=0.05
ok   deficit_pct                 RO-brine/RW conductivity-equivalent            reported=42.1 recomputed=42.1 abs_diff=0 tolerance=0.05
ok   deficit_pct                 RO-brine/RW composition                        reported=51.2 recomputed=51.2 abs_diff=0 tolerance=0.05
ok   ln_gH_gL                    Okinawa SW/RW                                  reported=-0.34 recomputed=-0.33773049 abs_diff=0.00226951 tolerance=0.005
ok   ln_gH_gL                    Okinawa RO-brine/RW                            reported=-0.36 recomputed=-0.36079838 abs_diff=0.000798382 tolerance=0.005
ok   alpha_eff                   SW/RW = 2t-1                                   reported=0.96 recomputed=0.96 abs_diff=0 tolerance=0.0001
ok   alpha_eff                   RO-brine/RW = 7.7/8.4                          reported=0.92 recomputed=0.91666667 abs_diff=0.00333333 tolerance=0.005
ok   X_eq_per_kg                 reproducing alpha 0.96                         reported=1 recomputed=1.0003571 abs_diff=0.000357111 tolerance=0.01
ok   X_eq_per_kg                 reproducing alpha 0.92                         reported=0.94 recomputed=0.94339202 abs_diff=0.00339202 tolerance=0.005
ok   X_eq_per_kg                 X_eff fitted to SW/RW                          reported=0.1 recomputed=0.10388505 abs_diff=0.00388505 tolerance=0.005
ok   ratio                       RO-brine/RW predicted with X_eff               reported=0.575 recomputed=0.57531148 abs_diff=0.000311476 tolerance=0.0005
ok   reverse_order_max_shift_pts all four cases                                 reported=1.2 recomputed=1.1899676 abs_diff=0.0100324 tolerance=0.05
ok   alpha_sensitivity_pts_per_0.01 SW/RW conductivity-equivalent                  reported=2.49 recomputed=2.494574 abs_diff=0.00457401 tolerance=0.005
ok   alpha_sensitivity_pts_per_0.01 SW/RW composition                              reported=1.99 recomputed=1.9911315 abs_diff=0.00113151 tolerance=0.005
ok   alpha_sensitivity_pts_per_0.01 RO-brine/RW conductivity-equivalent            reported=2.23 recomputed=2.226551 abs_diff=0.00344904 tolerance=0.005
ok   alpha_sensitivity_pts_per_0.01 RO-brine/RW composition                        reported=1.85 recomputed=1.8500329 abs_diff=3.28883e-05 tolerance=0.005
ok   alpha_for_residual_50pct    SW/RW conductivity-equivalent                  reported=0.869 recomputed=0.86855177 abs_diff=0.000448233 tolerance=0.0005
ok   alpha_for_residual_50pct    SW/RW composition                              reported=0.806 recomputed=0.80620649 abs_diff=0.000206495 tolerance=0.0005
ok   alpha_for_residual_50pct    RO-brine/RW conductivity-equivalent            reported=0.842 recomputed=0.84224298 abs_diff=0.000242978 tolerance=0.0005
ok   alpha_for_residual_50pct    RO-brine/RW composition                        reported=0.785 recomputed=0.78545901 abs_diff=0.00045901 tolerance=0.0005
ok   alpha_0.90                  membrane share min %                           reported=18.5 recomputed=18.500329 abs_diff=0.000328883 tolerance=0.05
ok   alpha_0.90                  membrane share max %                           reported=24.9 recomputed=24.94574 abs_diff=0.0457401 tolerance=0.05
ok   alpha_0.90                  residual min %                                 reported=57.8 recomputed=57.844995 abs_diff=0.0449946 tolerance=0.05
ok   alpha_0.90                  residual max %                                 reported=71.2 recomputed=71.19046 abs_diff=0.00954006 tolerance=0.05
ok   half_pair_V                 SW/RW conductivity-equivalent                  reported=0.13 recomputed=0.12578013 abs_diff=0.00421987 tolerance=0.005
ok   half_pair_V                 SW/RW composition                              reported=0.15 recomputed=0.15138117 abs_diff=0.00138117 tolerance=0.005
ok   molal_vs_molar_shift_pct    largest of four cases                          reported=0.36 recomputed=0.35909846 abs_diff=0.000901538 tolerance=0.01
ok   f_act_pct                   SW/RW conductivity-equivalent                  reported=6.45 recomputed=6.4534745 abs_diff=0.00347449 tolerance=0.005
ok   modeled_ratio               SW/RW conductivity-equivalent                  reported=0.898 recomputed=0.89804664 abs_diff=4.66449e-05 tolerance=0.0005
ok   f_act_pct                   SW/RW composition                              reported=5.42 recomputed=5.4212531 abs_diff=0.00125309 tolerance=0.005
ok   modeled_ratio               SW/RW composition                              reported=0.908 recomputed=0.90795597 abs_diff=4.40297e-05 tolerance=0.0005
ok   f_act_pct                   RO-brine/RW conductivity-equivalent            reported=6.26 recomputed=6.2622045 abs_diff=0.0022045 tolerance=0.005
ok   modeled_ratio               RO-brine/RW conductivity-equivalent            reported=0.862 recomputed=0.86238772 abs_diff=0.000387719 tolerance=0.0005
ok   f_act_pct                   RO-brine/RW composition                        reported=5.28 recomputed=5.2783161 abs_diff=0.00168388 tolerance=0.005
ok   modeled_ratio               RO-brine/RW composition                        reported=0.871 recomputed=0.87143949 abs_diff=0.000439492 tolerance=0.0005
ok   ocv_ratio_pm0.01_residual_shift_pts min                                            reported=0.4 recomputed=0.39954001 abs_diff=0.00045999 tolerance=0.05
ok   ocv_ratio_pm0.01_residual_shift_pts max                                            reported=0.8 recomputed=0.7953042 abs_diff=0.0046958 tolerance=0.05

RED reproducibility verification
PHREEQC calculations: outputs available (version logged separately)
Python calculations: completed
Figures generated: 2/2
Expected comparisons: 72
Passed: 72
Failed: 0
Maximum absolute discrepancy (across different units): 0.045740136
Comparison uses each row-specific absolute tolerance in expected/expected_values.csv.
Numerical consistency: PASS
All values reproduced
